| 00:00:428 sec. |
BRIAN LAMB, HOST, -
Michael Klare, author of "Rogue States and Nuclear Outlaws", how did you become defense correspondent for the Nation magazine? |
| 00:00:5020 sec. |
MICHAEL KLARE, AUTHOR, "ROUGE STATES AND NUCLEAR OUTLAWS", -
: When I lived in Washington many years ago, I found myself doing a lot of research on military affairs and contributing articles to various journals,... |
| 00:01:102 sec. |
LAMB, -
What were you doing in Washington at the time? |
| 00:01:129 sec. |
KLARE, -
I was working at the Institute for Policy Studies doing research on American foreign policy, militarization and the arms trade. |
| 00:01:216 sec. |
LAMB, -
Does Nation magazine have a defense policy you have to reflect in writing? |
| 00:01:2724 sec. |
KLARE, -
Oh, absolutely not. Nation is America's oldest political magazine, and it mainly covers domestic affairs, domestic politics, usually from a critical... |
| 00:01:515 sec. |
LAMB, -
We had David Korn on a recent program, and he said that Paul Newman owns part of the Nation these days. |
| 00:01:569 sec. |
KLARE, -
That's very recent. But this is a magazine that has a hundred year history, and he's just the latest of many distinguished people to come on ownership. |
| 00:02:052 sec. |
LAMB, -
Is there a slant to the Nation? |
| 00:02:0716 sec. |
KLARE, -
Oh, I would say there certainly is. There's one that tends to be suspicious of Washington, of American elites that are seen as governing the country,... |
| 00:02:235 sec. |
LAMB, -
Is there a liberal or conservative label you'd put on it? |
| 00:02:2838 sec. |
KLARE, -
I would say it's definitely on the left end of the spectrum of political analysis, but within that there's a lot of differences. On the issue of intervention,... |
| 00:03:064 sec. |
LAMB, -
What's the genesis of the book? When did you start thinking about writing it? |
| 00:03:1038 sec. |
KLARE, -
I started writing that when the fall of the Berlin Wall began. I could see American strategists sort of groping for a new raison d'ˆtre for American... |
| 00:03:486 sec. |
LAMB, -
Where do you work at this process? Where do you study the defense issues? |
| 00:03:5424 sec. |
KLARE, -
I work out of my office in Hampshire College, which is in Amherst, Massachusetts. But I come to Washington as frequently as I can to keep up with events,... |
| 00:04:183 sec. |
LAMB, -
Where did you get the title "Rogue States and Nuclear Outlaws"? |
| 00:04:2130 sec. |
KLARE, -
We were fishing for a way to describe this. This is a process that really began before Iraq invaded Kuwait. Afterwards the term "outlaw" began to be... |
| 00:04:512 sec. |
LAMB, -
What does "rogue" mean? |
| 00:04:5337 sec. |
KLARE, -
Rogue has been applied to different kinds of problem states in the past few years, but now it's being used to describe states that, for the most part,... |
| 00:05:302 sec. |
LAMB, -
Are they the only three? |
| 00:05:3226 sec. |
KLARE, -
No. Of course there's no official listing of rogue states. This is a manufactured term. But I think in Washington it's understood to include North Korea... |
| 00:05:586 sec. |
LAMB, -
If someone buys this book what do they get? |
| 00:06:0453 sec. |
KLARE, -
They'll get a few things out of it. One thing, I think, is a better understanding of what we're paying $270 billion a year for on our military budget.... |
| 00:06:571 sec. |
LAMB, -
What does that mean? |
| 00:06:5825 sec. |
KLARE, -
Proliferation refers to the spread of weapons of mass destruction, which, in turn, means nuclear, chemical and biological weapons. So countries that,... |
| 00:07:235 sec. |
LAMB, -
One of the first names you read in the book is Colin Powell. How come? |
| 00:07:2859 sec. |
KLARE, -
General Colin Powell, I think, is the man more than anyone else in the defense establishment who understood very early that the end of the Cold War... |
| 00:08:273 sec. |
LAMB, -
What did you learn about him in your study? |
| 00:08:3036 sec. |
KLARE, -
I think he's an extremely intelligent and thoughtful person. I think better than, for instance, the secretary of defense, Dick Cheney, he understood... |
| 00:09:062 sec. |
LAMB, -
How did you learn there was a difference between those two men? |
| 00:09:0842 sec. |
KLARE, -
There is a Pentagon history in process, a history of what's called a base force, which is what Colin Powell called his proposed post Cold War military,... |
| 00:09:503 sec. |
LAMB, -
Where did you find that history? |
| 00:09:5318 sec. |
KLARE, -
It's a Joint Chiefs of Staff publication through their history branch offered for sale from the U.S. Government Printing Office. I doubt many scholars... |
| 00:10:11 |
LAMB, -
How did you find it? |
| 00:10:1114 sec. |
KLARE, -
Listed in the Government Monthly circular of publications, which I check along with other documents to keep up with literature in the field. |
| 00:10:255 sec. |
LAMB, -
Would you not know that there was a difference between the two of them if you hadn't read this? |
| 00:10:3011 sec. |
KLARE, -
I would have suspected that was the case from their public presentations but not that it was as intense a dispute as comes out of this document. |
| 00:10:412 sec. |
LAMB, -
And when did they have their differences? |
| 00:10:4349 sec. |
KLARE, -
Between the fall of the Berlin Wall, which was November of 1989 and April or May of 1990. Now this was a crucial period for the U.S. because the Warsaw... |
| 00:11:32 |
LAMB, -
Who won? |
| 00:11:3226 sec. |
KLARE, -
Well, in the end, Colin Powell won. We know that because August 2, ironically, the day that Iraq invaded Kuwait, President Bush scheduled a speech in... |
| 00:11:587 sec. |
LAMB, -
Is this the same Aspen conference where Mrs. Thatcher told President Bush not to go wobbly on us? |
| 00:12:0531 sec. |
KLARE, -
Exactly. That is the one. It was scheduled long before there was any indication that anything was going to happen in Kuwait. The speech was written... |
| 00:12:362 sec. |
LAMB, -
Have you ever worked in politics? |
| 00:12:388 sec. |
KLARE, -
I have not worked in politics. I've certainly worked to support various candidates at different times. |
| 00:12:463 sec. |
LAMB, -
Who's your favorite candidate that speaks out on military issues? |
| 00:12:4935 sec. |
KLARE, -
I have to say I live in Massachusetts and I'm a supporter of Ted Kennedy, who just assisted in his reelection locally campaigning for him. As a home... |
| 00:13:241 sec. |
LAMB, -
Where is your home originally? |
| 00:13:259 sec. |
KLARE, -
New York City. Grew up in New York City. Went to high school and college at Columbia University in New York, so I'm a New York boy. |
| 00:13:341 sec. |
LAMB, -
What was your major? |
| 00:13:354 sec. |
KLARE, -
Art history and architecture as an undergraduate. |
| 00:13:392 sec. |
LAMB, -
How many other degrees do you have? |
| 00:13:4127 sec. |
KLARE, -
I was going to study architecture, and I went to graduate school in the field, got an M.A. in architectural history from Columbia and taught for a while... |
| 00:14:081 sec. |
LAMB, -
Do you have a Ph.D.? |
| 00:14:0916 sec. |
KLARE, -
Yes, in political scienc from the Union Institute in Cincinnati, Ohio. It's a consortial school supported by other colleges and universities for adult... |
| 00:14:252 sec. |
LAMB, -
And how did you get to Hampshire College? |
| 00:14:2722 sec. |
KLARE, -
I actually worked for a consortium, a very interesting program. It's a consortium of five schools. Hampshire College, Smith, Mount Holyoke, Amherst... |
| 00:14:492 sec. |
LAMB, -
Called the Five Sisters? |
| 00:14:513 sec. |
KLARE, -
No, we have two of the five sisters. |
| 00:14:544 sec. |
LAMB, -
Seven Sisters, that's right. Who are the other two? |
| 00:14:5813 sec. |
KLARE, -
I have Mount Holyoke and Smith out of the sisters. Then Hampshire and Amherst College, which are coed, and University of Massachusetts. So we're really... |
| 00:15:113 sec. |
LAMB, -
What's this institute, and how did it get its funding? |
| 00:15:1454 sec. |
KLARE, -
The five colleges, which are all close to each other, have created a consortial program called the Five College Consortium to sponsor joint programs... |
| 00:16:083 sec. |
LAMB, -
And so what kind of students would you have before you? |
| 00:16:1129 sec. |
KLARE, -
I get very bright, very disciplined students who are interested in international affairs and also interested in peace and security types of issues.... |
| 00:16:405 sec. |
LAMB, -
You dedicated this book to your father, Charles Klare. Is he alive? |
| 00:16:451 sec. |
KLARE, -
He's still alive. |
| 00:16:461 sec. |
LAMB, -
What's he do? |
| 00:16:4716 sec. |
KLARE, -
He's retired. He's a retired trade union organizer. He was based in New York City but worked for many years out of an office in Chicago, working for... |
| 00:17:0315 sec. |
LAMB, -
You dedicate it to your son, Alexander, you call Sasha. But he has an interesting last name. You take your wife's name and your name and reverse it? |
| 00:17:185 sec. |
KLARE, -
Well, we include both of our names. |
| 00:17:238 sec. |
LAMB, -
Your name comes first, her name second, so it's Klare-Ayvazian. Why did you dedicate it to your son? |
| 00:17:3157 sec. |
KLARE, -
I tried to hint in my dedication to the continuity in views that I hope would be passed on. My father was a trade union organizer and a supporter of... |
| 00:18:281 sec. |
LAMB, -
How old is your son? |
| 00:18:292 sec. |
KLARE, -
He'll be 7 in a week. |
| 00:18:312 sec. |
LAMB, -
And your wife, what does she do? |
| 00:18:3349 sec. |
KLARE, -
She also has a Ph.D. in ethnic studies, and she works with an organization known as Communitas, which does training and consulting with non-profit organizations... |
| 00:19:227 sec. |
LAMB, -
Which country in the world are you most concerned about and think we would most likely become involved? |
| 00:19:2956 sec. |
KLARE, -
The place I worry about most -- although right now things are looking a little better -- is North Korea. I worry about North Korea because, at this... |
| 00:20:251 min. |
KLARE, -
So the worry is that any breakdown in relations between North and South could produce a conflict that would be extremely destructive and deadly, where... |
| 00:21:3910 sec. |
LAMB, -
What's the worst thing that could happen to this country today, given its state of readiness, or lack of readiness, depending on what you think? |
| 00:21:4950 sec. |
KLARE, -
As I argue in my book, we're quite well prepared to fight another Operation Desert Storm. If Iraq were to start a fight with us, I think we could do... |
| 00:22:3951 sec. |
KLARE, -
Even if the United States were not directly involved, the consequences would spill over in our border, or likewise in Europe if Algeria were to disintegrate... |
| 00:23:3034 sec. |
LAMB, -
You quote a couple of people from New Delhi. One is Raja Mohan and the other is it Subrahmanyan. The quote concerns the idea that advanced industrial... |
| 00:24:041 min. |
KLARE, -
They're referring to the 19th century European colonial view that the white Christian races of Europe had a civilizing mission to take care of the less... |
| 00:25:435 sec. |
LAMB, -
When did you first get interested in military matters? |
| 00:25:484 sec. |
KLARE, -
During the Vietnam War period, like others of my generation. |
| 00:25:521 sec. |
LAMB, -
How old were you then? |
| 00:25:531 sec. |
KLARE, -
I was a college student. |
| 00:25:545 sec. |
LAMB, -
Were you active either for or against the war? |
| 00:25:591 min. |
KLARE, -
I was active in the peace movement to end the conflict. I was at Columbia University, and I became particularly interested in the roles universities... |
| 00:27:159 sec. |
LAMB, -
If you could run the military establishment, run the country and change the way we deal with military and weaponry and what we buy, what would you do? |
| 00:27:241 min. |
KLARE, -
What I would do in particular, I would begin with the issue of strategy, and I think Colin Powell was absolutely right that that's the beginning point... |
| 00:28:316 sec. |
LAMB, -
What is the comparison with the number of men and women under arms that we had in 1989 versus what we have in 1995? |
| 00:28:3710 sec. |
KLARE, -
It's declining from just under 2 million or so down to about 1.4 million. |
| 00:28:472 sec. |
LAMB, -
Is that enough? |
| 00:28:4931 sec. |
KLARE, -
I think that that's still probably too many people to keep in uniform, but it's not only a question of numbers. It's how are they organized. The current... |
| 00:29:202 sec. |
LAMB, -
How many people in an Army division? |
| 00:29:222 sec. |
KLARE, -
Oh, about 20,000, give or take. |
| 00:29:245 sec. |
LAMB, -
How many people in a carrier-- you say a task group? |
| 00:29:2916 sec. |
KLARE, -
A carrier battle group. I don't know how many people. It's about 10 to15 ships, and the aircraft carrier itself has about 6,000 people on board. So... |
| 00:29:456 sec. |
LAMB, -
How much of what we do in the military is moved by industry? |
| 00:29:511 min. |
KLARE, -
I think that a lot of what's happening now is being moved by industry's particular needs to maintain certain kinds of production lines going that, in... |
| 00:31:261 sec. |
LAMB, -
What is? |
| 00:31:2749 sec. |
KLARE, -
I really do believe that is the institutional interests of the military, like any big organization, facing the prospects of downsizing and reduction,... |
| 00:32:169 sec. |
LAMB, -
If Colin Powell announced for president or you saw him on the ticket, from what you know of studying him, what would your reaction be? |
| 00:32:2534 sec. |
KLARE, -
I'd want to see what his policies really are. I think Colin Powell is a very thoughtful, intelligent man, and I think he's been really cagey about what... |
| 00:32:596 sec. |
LAMB, -
Not to over-characterize it, but you're somewhat critical of Les Aspin. Why? |
| 00:33:0556 sec. |
KLARE, -
I'm critical of Les Aspin because he came in promising to take a fresh look at defense policy -- that's what he promised -- and he coins this term of... |
| 00:34:014 sec. |
LAMB, -
How would you characterize current Secretary of Defense William Perry? |
| 00:34:0529 sec. |
KLARE, -
I think William Perry is a very thoughtful person, a good manager. I don't think he has the same kind of strategic depth and interests that Les Aspin... |
| 00:34:345 sec. |
LAMB, -
What about Bill Clinton's view of what the military ought to do? |
| 00:34:3932 sec. |
KLARE, -
Bill Clinton I also fault, because he, too, said when he was elected that he would take a fresh look at defense policy, and I think he's just abandoned... |
| 00:35:112 sec. |
LAMB, -
How much do you write for the Nation? |
| 00:35:136 sec. |
KLARE, -
I write every three to six months. I write for other publications as well. |
| 00:35:199 sec. |
LAMB, -
When you write something for the Nation, how do you decide what readers will be interested in? |
| 00:35:2855 sec. |
KLARE, -
They expect me to be writing something that's critical of government policy, because that's what you would turn to the Nation for is a critical look.... |
| 00:36:2311 sec. |
LAMB, -
What do you use and read to understand what's going on with the military? |
| 00:36:341 min. |
KLARE, -
I personally believe that you can't work in this field unless you're familiar with and understand what people in the military are saying. I subscribe... |
| 00:37:392 sec. |
LAMB, -
How do you rate press coverage of the military? |
| 00:37:4132 sec. |
KLARE, -
I think that press coverage of the military is good on kind of the big-ticket procurement issues. When there's debate over a weapons system and it costs... |
| 00:38:133 sec. |
LAMB, -
What do you find students that you teach interested in? |
| 00:38:161 min. |
KLARE, -
I don't always know what they're most interested in, but students are interested a lot in the emerging world, how the world is changing. The Cold War,... |
| 00:39:302 sec. |
LAMB, -
How would you define their politics today? |
| 00:39:3247 sec. |
KLARE, -
I would define their politics as skeptical of anything that comes from government leaders, whether the leaders are left, right or something else, from... |
| 00:40:191 sec. |
LAMB, -
Where does this come from? |
| 00:40:201 min. |
KLARE, -
I think it comes partly from a way in which -- especially in the Reagan era when these young people were growing up -- a tendency to look down on the... |
| 00:41:213 sec. |
LAMB, -
When you wrote this book, who did you envision reading it? |
| 00:41:2440 sec. |
KLARE, -
I hoped that policy makers would read it. I don't know how successful we'll be at that, but I certainly hope that they would. I certainly hope that... |
| 00:42:042 sec. |
LAMB, -
Why has the public been deprived? |
| 00:42:0642 sec. |
KLARE, -
I think that there are a couple of reasons why. One of them is that the process in which these decisions were made were so far removed from public consciousness... |
| 00:42:482 sec. |
LAMB, -
Was there no follow-up in hearings on the Hill? |
| 00:42:5040 sec. |
KLARE, -
That I was going to come to. The second thing that happened was the Persian Gulf War broke out and so consumed people's attention that the debate promised... |
| 00:43:304 sec. |
LAMB, -
How would you rate American military in relation to other world militaries? |
| 00:43:3445 sec. |
KLARE, -
We spend more on our military than the rest of the world spends combined on their military. So we have the most well-endowed military in the world.... |
| 00:44:194 sec. |
LAMB, -
Go over the things that you think are most needed. |
| 00:44:2321 sec. |
KLARE, -
The things I think are most needed are multilateral, multinational peacekeeping and peace enforcement operation and humanitarian aid and rescue. The... |
| 00:44:445 sec. |
LAMB, -
Why should that be our mission? Why is it the role of this country to do that? |
| 00:44:4957 sec. |
KLARE, -
I don't think it's the role of this country to do it by itself. Let me make that very clear. We should only do it as part of multinational UN or NATO... |
| 00:45:464 sec. |
LAMB, -
Do you have any problem with the American military being under the command of a U.N. commander? |
| 00:45:5029 sec. |
KLARE, -
I have no problem of American soldiers being under the command of a U.N. officer if the United States has a role in the Security Council of choosing... |
| 00:46:1921 sec. |
LAMB, -
Earlier, you named the five countries that legally under the Nuclear Nonproliferation Treaty can have nuclear weapons -- China, France, Great Britain,... |
| 00:46:4023 sec. |
KLARE, -
Those are the countries that were the declared nuclear powers and had tested nuclear weapons when the Nuclear Nonproliferation Treaty was signed in... |
| 00:47:033 sec. |
LAMB, -
Who, in your opinion, has nuclear capabilities? |
| 00:47:0615 sec. |
KLARE, -
The three de facto nuclear powers today are India, Pakistan and Israel. All of those countries are believed to have functioning nuclear weapons that... |
| 00:47:211 sec. |
LAMB, -
Do they admit it? |
| 00:47:225 sec. |
KLARE, -
They hint at it. They don't actually say it. |
| 00:47:272 sec. |
LAMB, -
Have they signed the treaty? |
| 00:47:292 sec. |
KLARE, -
They have not signed the treaty. |
| 00:47:311 sec. |
LAMB, -
They're not violating anything? |
| 00:47:3228 sec. |
KLARE, -
They themselves are not violating, but if American companies or European companies or Russian companies sell equipment to those countries that's used... |
| 00:48:007 sec. |
LAMB, -
In one way or the other, 3 billion of our dollars go to Israel every year. Money goes to Pakistan. Do we have any money that goes to India? |
| 00:48:0741 sec. |
KLARE, -
We don't right now. We're not supplying Pakistan with aid. It's the one country that has been penalized under the nuclear nonproliferation act to be... |
| 00:48:484 sec. |
LAMB, -
Now, what about other countries? |
| 00:48:521 min. |
KLARE, -
Other countries have pursued nuclear weapons at one time or another -- most important, South Africa, which admits to having produced seven nuclear bombs.... |
| 00:50:081 min. |
KLARE, -
They are now obligated under an agreement with the United States to dismantle that capability under supervision, though there's debate about what the... |
| 00:51:193 sec. |
LAMB, -
Does the NPT have a sunset? |
| 00:51:2240 sec. |
KLARE, -
The NPT does have a sunset. It's coming up very quickly. It's in May of this year. The 25th anniversary of the NPT will come up, and the member states... |
| 00:52:0214 sec. |
LAMB, -
You talked about your days at Columbia and protesting the Vietnam War. In your opinion, is there a legacy as a result of the Vietnam War in this country? |
| 00:52:161 min. |
KLARE, -
I certainly think there's a legacy. I think we really haven't come to terms in this society with the divisions this conflict produced. We know there... |
| 00:54:021 sec. |
LAMB, -
Have you ever served in the military? |
| 00:54:0318 sec. |
KLARE, -
I have not. I've spent a lot of time with people in the military, and I respect them a great deal. I've gone as a journalist on military maneuvers around... |
| 00:54:212 sec. |
LAMB, -
How long have you been at Hampshire College? |
| 00:54:231 sec. |
KLARE, -
Ten years. |
| 00:54:241 sec. |
LAMB, -
When was the college formed? |
| 00:54:2532 sec. |
KLARE, -
The college was formed 25 years ago. We're celebrating our 25th anniversary this spring. Hampshire is an interesting college, by the way. It was formed... |
| 00:54:573 sec. |
LAMB, -
You mentioned the others being Amherst and Smith? |
| 00:55:005 sec. |
KLARE, -
Mount Holyoke and the University of Massachusetts at Amherst. |
| 00:55:051 sec. |
LAMB, -
Do they own Hampshire? |
| 00:55:0612 sec. |
KLARE, -
No, originally they supplied many of the people on the board of trustees and supplied a lot of the original administrators, but it's an independent... |
| 00:55:181 sec. |
LAMB, -
What's unusual? |
| 00:55:1917 sec. |
KLARE, -
Well, Hampshire's probably most noted -- it doesn't give grades. Instead, students receive written evaluations of their work. So there isn't this pressure... |
| 00:55:362 sec. |
LAMB, -
Do you have any pass-fail at all? |
| 00:55:3822 sec. |
KLARE, -
No pass-fail. However, you can't graduate without passing a number of hurdles or examinations. Our seniors have to write a thesis that's often equivalent... |
| 00:56:004 sec. |
LAMB, -
What are most of the degrees in? What do they study? |
| 00:56:0436 sec. |
KLARE, -
A lot of the students are interested in the arts and humanities. I think that would be our strongest, most well-known suit. In particular, Ken Burns,... |
| 00:56:403 sec. |
LAMB, -
From your experience are there any drawbacks to this kind of a school? |
| 00:56:4340 sec. |
KLARE, -
I think that it's a problem for students who cannot be self-directed in their work. It's ideal for young people who come in who have a strong interest... |
| 00:57:231 sec. |
LAMB, -
Where is it located? |
| 00:57:243 sec. |
KLARE, -
It's in Amherst, Massachusetts. |
| 00:57:271 sec. |
LAMB, -
And how many students do you have? |
| 00:57:281 sec. |
KLARE, -
Eleven hundred. |
| 00:57:2910 sec. |
LAMB, -
The author is Michael Klare, Rogue States and Nuclear Outlaws. Thank you. |
| 00:57:3948 sec. |
KLARE, -
It's been my pleasure. |