| 00:00:186 min. |
The CHAIRMAN
This hearing of the Senate Foreign Relations Committee is called to order. The committee meets today to examine United States policy toward Iran,... |
| 00:06:335 sec. |
Senator BIDEN
Thank you, Mr. Chairman. I’d ask unanimous consent that my entire statement be placed in the record, as if read. |
| 00:06:38 |
The CHAIRMAN
It will be placed in the record in full. |
| 00:06:381 min. |
Senator BIDEN
And let me just say that, to state the obvious, Iran’s failed to comply. This is a very important moment for a real test for our diplomacy,... |
| 00:08:0110 sec. |
The CHAIRMAN
Thank you very much, Senator Biden. We look now to you, Secretary Burns. Your full statement will be made a part of the record. And please... |
| 00:08:1117 min. |
Mr. BURNS
Mr. Chairman, thank you very much for the invitation to be with you. And Senator Biden, other members of the committee, thank you very much... |
| 00:25:384 min. |
The CHAIRMAN
Well, thank you very much, Secretary Burns. The Chair notes that we have good attendance, with perhaps more coming; and, likewise, a distinguished... |
| 00:30:004 min. |
Mr. BURNS
Mr. Chairman, thank you. I think you’ve asked a central question. What are the objectives of the Iranian Government? What type of world... |
| 00:34:1830 sec. |
The CHAIRMAN
My time has concluded. I appreciate the thought that all of us—people in public life and Americans—might become much better informed about... |
| 00:34:488 min. |
Senator BIDEN
Thank you, Mr. Chairman. Let me say, at the outset, I don’t have a question. Nick, I’m more encouraged by what you said today than anything I’ve... |
| 00:43:05 |
The CHAIRMAN
Thank you very much, Senator Biden. Senator Hagel. |
| 00:43:056 min. |
Senator HAGEL
Mr. Chairman, thank you. Secretary Burns, welcome. I would like to follow along the comments of Chairman Lugar and Senator Biden, Mr. Secretary,... |
| 00:49:384 min. |
Mr. BURNS
Thank you very much. Thanks, Senator Hagel. VerDate 11-MAY-2000 13:50 Nov 20, 2006 Jkt 000000 PO 00000 Frm 00024 Fmt 6633 Sfmt 6602 IRAN19.SEN... |
| 00:54:338 sec. |
Senator HAGEL
Well, actually, you’ve not. If I—I know you wanted to keep a tight rein on this, Mr. Chairman, but I asked the question, Under what condition... |
| 00:54:412 min. |
Mr. BURNS
And I would answer that question, respectfully and specifically, by saying, Mr. Chairman, we haven’t taken any option off the table, but... |
| 00:56:59 |
Senator HAGEL
Thank you. |
| 00:56:5928 sec. |
Senator BIDEN
I’d like to ask unanimous consent that—on this point, that the testimony in response to a question by me when Secretary Rice was here, in... |
| 00:57:27 |
The CHAIRMAN
It will be made a part of the record. [The information previously referred to follows:] NOMINATION HEARING OF DR. CONDOLEEZZA RICE TO BE... |
| 00:57:27 |
Senator BIDEN
Iran. Seymour Hersch wrote, in The New Yorker, that the ‘‘Hawks in the Pentagon, in private discussions, have been urging a limited attack on... |
| 00:57:27 |
Dr. RICE
The goal of the administration is to have a regime in Iran that is responsive to concerns that we have about Iran’s policies, which are 180 degrees... |
| 00:57:27 |
Senator BIDEN
One of the things that—if I can stick on the nuclear side of this equation for a minute, one of the things that I’ve found—I may be mistaken,... |
| 00:57:27 |
Dr. RICE
Well, it’s hard to—I really don’t want to speculate. I think it’s the kind of thing that we’ve—we don’t know. I do think that we’re sending a... |
| 00:57:27 |
Senator BIDEN
Well, we did—— |
| 00:57:27 |
Dr. RICE [continuing]
Whatever regime there is in—— |
| 00:57:27 |
Senator BIDEN [continuing]
That, and—— |
| 00:57:27 |
Dr. RICE [continuing]
Iran. |
| 00:57:27 |
Senator BIDEN [continuing]
And you did it very successfully, along with our European friends, who had initiated it, with regard to Qaddafi. But, as I said earlier, there... |
| 00:57:27 |
Dr. RICE
Well, we do have a number of other problems with Iran, not just the nuclear problem. And I think that the future of Iranian relations—United States/ Iranian... |
| 00:57:27 |
Senator BIDEN
I understand that. And I think you’ve given me a straightforward answer, and I want to make sure I don’t misunderstand you. When I talk to our European... |
| 00:57:27 |
Dr. RICE
Well, I think we would have to say that the relationship with Iran has more components than the nuclear side, but let’s see how far the Europeans... |
| 00:57:27 |
Senator BIDEN
Well—— |
| 00:57:27 |
Dr. RICE [continuing]
Take a look at—— |
| 00:57:27 |
Senator BIDEN [continuing]
I appreciate—— |
| 00:57:27 |
Dr. RICE [continuing]
Where we are. |
| 00:57:278 sec. |
Senator BIDEN [continuing]
That. I would just suggest that we have a real relationship with China, and their human-rights abuses are terrible. The watch group looking... |
| 00:57:35 |
The CHAIRMAN
Thank you, Senator Hagel. Senator Feingold. |
| 00:57:352 min. |
Senator FEINGOLD
Thank you, Mr. Chairman, for holding this very important hearing. And, Secretary Burns, as always, it’s good to see you, and to listen to... |
| 00:59:5649 sec. |
Mr. BURNS
Senator, I’m happy to answer that question, if you’d like me to. The Indians—India was the first of the nonaligned countries to vote... |
| 01:00:45 |
Senator FEINGOLD
So, you just assume that the Prime Minister’s words don’t mean what they say? |
| 01:00:4545 sec. |
Mr. BURNS
Well, you know, lots of countries have different relations with Iran. Some of our best allies in NATO—the European countries—have multibillion-dollar... |
| 01:01:3037 sec. |
Senator FEINGOLD
Well, I assume obtaining India’s support for such sanctions would be one of our highest priorities with our relationship with India, just... |
| 01:02:07 |
Mr. BURNS
Yeah. |
| 01:02:07 |
Senator FEINGOLD
If you could react to that. |
| 01:02:0740 sec. |
Mr. BURNS
There have been stories for the past year and a half that that pipeline is under consideration. In our conversations with the Pakistani... |
| 01:02:47 |
Senator FEINGOLD
I’d appreciate—— |
| 01:02:47 |
Mr. BURNS [continuing]
It may be currently being discussed, but I’m not sure there have been any significant agreements that would, you know, put it into motion.... |
| 01:02:4721 sec. |
Senator FEINGOLD
Appreciate that answer, look forward to the written answer, Mr. Secretary. Can you give me an update on the administration’s democracy promotion... |
| 01:03:0857 sec. |
Mr. BURNS
Senator, we’re grateful for the funding by the Congress for our democracy programs. Our democracy programs have no other purpose than to... |
| 01:04:05 |
Senator FEINGOLD
How effective—— |
| 01:04:05 |
Mr. BURNS [continuing]
North America—— |
| 01:04:055 sec. |
Senator FEINGOLD [continuing]
Is this being, though? You know, I understand that the intentions probably were equally appropriate with regard to Iraq, but there are serious... |
| 01:04:10 |
Mr. BURNS
I think it’s—— |
| 01:04:10 |
Senator FEINGOLD [continuing]
It working? |
| 01:04:1020 sec. |
Mr. BURNS
To be honest, I think it’s too early to answer that question. You’ve—you asked a good question, because you gave us VerDate 11-MAY-2000... |
| 01:04:30 |
Senator FEINGOLD
Are we taking—— |
| 01:04:30 |
Mr. BURNS [continuing]
Starting those efforts over the last—— |
| 01:04:305 sec. |
Senator FEINGOLD [continuing]
Into account lessons—— |
| 01:04:35 |
Mr. BURNS [continuing]
Couple of—— |
| 01:04:35 |
Senator FEINGOLD [continuing]
Learned from problems with this kind of attempt in Iraq? |
| 01:04:3540 sec. |
Mr. BURNS
In everything we do, we try to learn from past experience. We try to be good at what we do, and effective. And, obviously, if we—if there... |
| 01:05:1525 sec. |
Senator FEINGOLD
I thank you for all of that, and I just want to say—obviously, of course, you always want to be mindful of lessons learned, but the Iraq... |
| 01:05:4045 sec. |
Mr. BURNS
I just wanted to say, I think we have an obligation to come forward, maybe after a few more months have passed, and give you an accounting... |
| 01:06:25 |
Senator FEINGOLD
I strongly agree with you on that point, and I thank you, Mr. Secretary. Thank you, Mr. Chairman. |
| 01:06:255 sec. |
The CHAIRMAN
Thank you very much, Senator Feingold. Senator Allen. |
| 01:06:305 min. |
Senator ALLEN
Thank you, Mr. Chairman. This is obviously a very good time to hold this hearing, as the United Nations, at the same podium, will hear from... |
| 01:11:523 min. |
Mr. BURNS
Senator Allen, thank you very much. And may I just take this moment—forgive me for doing it—by thanking all of you for your support for... |
| 01:15:08 |
Senator ALLEN
Thank you, Secretary Burns. |
| 01:15:08 |
Mr. BURNS
Thank you, Senator. |
| 01:15:08 |
Senator ALLEN
Appreciate your great leadership, knowledge, and experience. |
| 01:15:08 |
Mr. BURNS
Thank you. |
| 01:15:08 |
The CHAIRMAN
Thank you, Senator Allen. |
| 01:15:087 sec. |
Senator Voinovich
|
| 01:15:152 min. |
Senator VOINOVICH
Mr. Chairman, thank you for having this meeting today. And welcome, Secretary Burns. First of all, I congratulate the administration on... |
| 01:18:0840 sec. |
Mr. BURNS
Senator Voinovich, thank you. I think you’re right to start with President Ahmadinejad. He’s addressing the U.N. General Assembly later... |
| 01:18:4817 sec. |
Senator VOINOVICH
What about the Sunnis and their relationship toward Iran? Are the Sunnis concerned about Iran’s policies and their President? |
| 01:19:0515 sec. |
Mr. BURNS
Senator, I—I’m not in a position to speak for each of the Arab governments, but I can say, in general, there is a great deal of concern—in... |
| 01:19:20 |
Senator VOINOVICH
Are the Sunni countries helping us on this issue? |
| 01:19:2045 sec. |
Mr. BURNS [continuing]
The Iranian Government. In many ways, yes. In many ways, yes. And you asked a very important question about the coalition that we... |
| 01:20:0540 sec. |
Senator VOINOVICH
Will they support sanctions that are significant enough to have an impact on the citizens of Iran so that people would start to question... |
| 01:20:4526 sec. |
Mr. BURNS
Right. I believe that the coalition against Iran will stay together. And, should the Iranians, within the next week or so, not suspend—agree... |
| 01:21:11 |
Senator VOINOVICH
You’re confident that the sanctions really will make a difference? |
| 01:21:1138 sec. |
Mr. BURNS
That’s a different question. We hope the sanctions will make a difference. The agreement we have in the Perm-5, among all the countries,... |
| 01:21:49 |
Senator VOINOVICH
You’re hopeful, but you’re not confident. |
| 01:21:4958 sec. |
Mr. BURNS
I can’t—I can’t testify to you that I’m 100 percent sure that any sanctions regime will have an absolute effect that you want on the Iranian... |
| 01:22:47 |
Senator VOINOVICH
I hate to—— |
| 01:22:47 |
Mr. BURNS [continuing]
If what happened—— |
| 01:22:4711 sec. |
Senator VOINOVICH [continuing]
Interrupt you, but will sanctions have any influence on Iran’s behavior toward Iraq or Iran’s policy of meddling in the Lebanon-Israeli... |
| 01:22:5822 sec. |
Mr. BURNS
First and foremost, these sanctions would be designed to have an impact on their nuclear policy and on their present disinclination to abide... |
| 01:23:2036 sec. |
Senator VOINOVICH
Well, I hope you’re right. I think the real question must be: What influence will sanctions have on the Iranian people and what they believe... |
| 01:23:561 min. |
Mr. BURNS
If I could just say—I don’t know if time is up, Mr. Chairman—but I think you’ve asked, you know, a central question, Senator, and that’s... |
| 01:25:47 |
Senator VOINOVICH
Thank you. |
| 01:25:47 |
Mr. BURNS
Thank you. |
| 01:25:4712 sec. |
The CHAIRMAN
Thank you very much, Senator Voinovich. Now, I’m going to recognize Senator Obama for his 8 minutes, and then this will conclude our questioning... |
| 01:25:591 min. |
Senator OBAMA
Thank you, Mr. Chairman. I apologize for being late. I had a conflict. Secretary Burns, I missed much of your testimony, so forgive me if... |
| 01:27:44 |
Mr. BURNS
Senator Obama, thank you very much. VerDate 11-MAY-2000 13:50 Nov 20, 2006 Jkt 000000 PO 00000 Frm 00038 Fmt 6633 Sfmt 6602 IRAN19.SEN sforel1... |
| 01:27:44 |
Senator OBAMA
I recognize that. |
| 01:27:442 min. |
Mr. BURNS [continuing]
In this session, answer your question as best I can by saying that Russia and the United States have very different views about Iran, in... |
| 01:30:2922 sec. |
Senator OBAMA
But you feel confident that—should the Iranians not take advantage of the opportunity to work something out here in the final hours—you... |
| 01:30:5139 sec. |
Mr. BURNS
I do. As well as China—the key question will be, what type of sanctions? I don’t think there’s any argument among the P–5. If Iran doesn’t... |
| 01:31:3015 sec. |
Senator OBAMA
Give me a sense of the differences in terms of how—without getting into every last detail—United States and Russian and Chinese perceptions... |
| 01:31:451 min. |
Mr. BURNS
Here’s where we agree, and I’ll tell you where we disagree, or where I think we may disagree. We all agree that you won’t put everything... |
| 01:33:172 min. |
Senator OBAMA
Last question, I’m running short on time here, and this goes to a broader issue. And that is, our posture toward Iran regarding their own... |
| 01:35:352 min. |
Mr. BURNS
Senator, thank you for that question. First, we are not modeling the present solution for the Iran nuclear crisis on the Agreed Framework... |
| 01:38:34 |
The CHAIRMAN
Thank you very much, Senator Obama. Senator Dodd has asked to raise one question, and of course we will assent to the Senator. |
| 01:38:347 sec. |
Senator Dodd
|
| 01:38:411 min. |
Senator DODD
Thank you very much, Mr. Chairman. I apologize to my colleagues here and the witnesses and Under Secretary, to you, for being late getting... |
| 01:40:061 min. |
Mr. BURNS
Senator Dodd, we have tried to be very careful and prudent in putting forward information to you, and to the public, that we believe is... |
| 01:41:2020 sec. |
Senator DODD
Well, it would be very, very helpful to all of us here, because we rely—we like to rely—we get that much contradiction from responsible... |
| 01:41:4023 sec. |
Mr. BURNS
Well I would just like to say, we have no reason to question the intentions of the framers of the House report, we just haven’t—I haven’t... |
| 01:42:035 sec. |
Senator DODD
Well, the language was pretty strong, so if you’d get back to us on that, I’d appreciate it very much. |
| 01:42:0817 sec. |
The CHAIRMAN
Thank you, Senator Dodd. A very sincere thanks to you, Secretary Burns, for your testimony today, your forthcoming responses to our questions,... |
| 01:42:25 |
Mr. BURNS
Thank you, Mr. Chairman. Thank you. |
| 01:42:251 min. |
The CHAIRMAN
The Chair would like to call now our second panel today, Dr. Ray Takeyh, senior fellow for Middle Eastern Studies, Council on Foreign Relations;... |
| 01:44:008 min. |
Dr. TAKEYH
Thank you, Mr. Chairman, for inviting me back to the committee, I’ll stay well within my 10-minute limitation, I have submitted my full... |
| 01:52:0013 sec. |
The CHAIRMAN
Well, thank you very much, Dr. Takeyh. Will you please proceed, Secretary Carter? STATEMENT OF HON. ASHTON B. CARTER, CODIRECTOR, PREVENTIVE DEFENSE... |
| 01:52:1318 min. |
Mr. CARTER
Mr. Chairman and members, thank you for inviting me to be here today to discuss the alternative courses of action if the diplomatic course... |
| 02:10:4124 sec. |
The CHAIRMAN
Thank you very much, Mr. Carter. Ambassador Indyk. STATEMENT OF HON. MARTIN S. INDYK, DIRECTOR, THE SABAN CENTER FOR MIDDLE... |
| 02:11:0510 min. |
Mr. INDYK
I will try to summarize it very quickly. Mr. Chairman, you pointed out that I had tried to deal with the Iranian issues when I was Assistant... |
| 02:21:2040 sec. |
The CHAIRMAN
Well, thank you very much, Ambassador Indyk. Let me just say that, procedurally now, we are about 3 or 4 minutes away from a rollcall vote.... |
| 02:22:002 min. |
Senator HAGEL [presiding]
That’s a risky proposition, leaving me in charge, but we will proceed in spite of that. It will not be voted on. Thank you, Senator Dodd.... |
| 02:24:511 min. |
Dr. TAKEYH
The congruity of having exchange programs while imposing a travel ban, I think that’s what we’re talking about. I VerDate 11-MAY-2000 13:50... |
| 02:26:44 |
Senator HAGEL
Thank you. Ash. |
| 02:26:442 min. |
Mr. CARTER
Senator, I can only put the following interpretation on what Under Secretary Burns said, because I agree with you that getting an education... |
| 02:29:10 |
Senator HAGEL
Thank you. Martin. |
| 02:29:102 min. |
Mr. INDYK
Well, Senator Hagel, I think you really put your finger on a larger problem, which is the contradiction in the administration’s approach... |
| 02:32:09 |
Senator HAGEL
Thank you. Senator Biden. |
| 02:32:0929 sec. |
Senator BIDEN
Do you both agree with that last statement? That the most effective thing is to isolate them diplomatically, and that almost any configuration... |
| 02:32:382 min. |
Dr. TAKEYH
I think we’re all in agreement that there is sort of a sanctions regime that is contemplated. For it to be effective multilateral is unlikely... |
| 02:35:20 |
Senator BIDEN
Thank you. Ash. |
| 02:35:2039 sec. |
Mr. CARTER
I just, very briefly, I agree with your contention, Senator Biden, with my two colleagues. There is a sense, however, and I noted this earlier,... |
| 02:35:5916 sec. |
Senator BIDEN
Excuse me, I’m not asking whether they have a political effect; I’m asking whether or not it’s possible to get the sanctions. In other words,... |
| 02:36:151 min. |
Mr. CARTER
I’m sorry, then, that I also agree with the sanctions we can get will not be effective, and the sanctions you can imagine being effective,... |
| 02:37:332 min. |
Senator BIDEN
That’s—without ruining your reputation—I agree with you completely. That’s been the thesis on which I’ve been operating, that (a) there... |
| 02:39:5955 sec. |
Mr. INDYK
Well, first of all, on the timeline, Senator Biden, I think it’s important to bear in mind that while you and Ash are correct at this time... |
| 02:40:541 min. |
Senator BIDEN
Well, let’s assume that’s true. There aren’t many options anybody has laid out to do anything about that. In other words, I mean, we have... |
| 02:42:27 |
Mr. INDYK
Well, we’re left with the choice between bad options. |
| 02:42:279 sec. |
Senator BIDEN
Well, I haven’t even heard any option that is not bad, we’re left with a choice between disastrous options. |
| 02:42:36 |
Mr. INDYK
Well, no, I wouldn’t go that far, I mean—— |
| 02:42:3613 sec. |
Senator BIDEN
Well, military force, use of military force in the near term—is that an option that does anything to generate or benefit our short-term... |
| 02:42:4911 sec. |
Mr. INDYK
Ash should answer that, but I mean, we should not abandon the diplomatic option just at the moment when it’s going to be really tested,... |
| 02:43:00 |
Senator BIDEN
I’m not suggesting that. |
| 02:43:0039 sec. |
Mr. INDYK [continuing]
We have to pursue that first and foremost. And there is a military option. Ash has laid out a lot of problems with that, but I think, ultimately,... |
| 02:43:3941 sec. |
Senator BIDEN
Well, I would argue that there is an interim step in there within the timeframe we’re talking about, but that’s a different issue. Let me... |
| 02:44:2015 sec. |
Mr. CARTER
I’m not an expert, Senator, on oil markets, but my understanding is that we would just end up buying oil from Venezuela, and somebody whose... |
| 02:44:35 |
Senator BIDEN
I think it’s important for the record that that be stated. |
| 02:44:351 min. |
Mr. CARTER
It would have no effect on Iran or on us, for that matter. May I touch on this question of the Israelis and the knowl- VerDate 11-MAY-2000... |
| 02:46:3315 sec. |
Senator BIDEN
Well, I noticed that the new Israeli Ministry of Intelligence has stopped using the phrase ‘‘point of no return.’’ And I’m at the point... |
| 02:46:481 min. |
Senator DODD
Well, thank you, Mr. Chairman, and thank all three of you for your continuing help and support and trying to shed some light on a very,... |
| 02:47:523 min. |
Dr. TAKEYH
I’ll just begin. In terms of negotiating options with Iran, I think what Senator Biden was referring to that, what are the options to negotiate. First... |
| 02:51:032 min. |
Mr. CARTER
It’s an excellent question—it’s the key question— what would we be satisfied with? Ray’s given a version of it that I think is quite cogent,... |
| 02:53:221 min. |
Senator DODD
Do you think that satisfies Iran? I was intrigued by Martin’s point earlier, and I was telling the chairman on our way over to vote, without... |
| 02:54:2312 sec. |
Mr. CARTER
The result I described, which was purely a nuclear result, is unlikely—in my judgment—to be attained in isolation. It will be part of some... |
| 02:54:35 |
Senator DODD
Right. |
| 02:54:3525 sec. |
Mr. CARTER
And the larger package will cut both ways for the Iranian leadership. To some extent it will legitimize them and reward the roll they’re... |
| 02:55:00 |
Senator DODD
That’s right. |
| 02:55:0030 sec. |
Mr. CARTER
And, I’m sure there’s some who want to have the bomb, and nothing can turn them around, others who want to have VerDate 11-MAY-2000 13:50... |
| 02:55:30 |
Senator DODD
Ambassador, do you want to add anything to this? |
| 02:55:3025 sec. |
Mr. INDYK
I don’t think I spoke to that same high-level leader, but I did hear one of them here just recently speak in what I would assume would be... |
| 02:55:55 |
Senator DODD
In fact, that was the same message. |
| 02:55:552 min. |
Mr. INDYK
And that’s a very real fear that they have in the region. But I just want to come back to what I thought was very useful explanation on... |
| 02:58:3543 sec. |
Senator DODD
Someone suggested that we take some sort of a bold action here to break through and start the process. I like, by the way, the analogy going... |
| 02:59:1812 sec. |
Mr. INDYK
We would love to do that, the Bush administration would love to do that, the Iranians have never been prepared to allow us. They have... |
| 02:59:3015 sec. |
Senator DODD
Have we made a public offering? I don’t recall ever seeing that kind of a public expression of offering that exchange of intersections being... |
| 02:59:4516 sec. |
Mr. INDYK
Well, our interests are represented by the Swiss—I forget who represents their interests, Pakistan—but in terms of actually being able to,... |
| 03:00:01 |
Senator DODD
They’ve been resistant to this. Mr. Chairman, I’ve got a dozen more questions, but I can see the look on your face and the look on these—I... |
| 03:00:015 min. |
The CHAIRMAN
It will be placed in the record. [The prepared statement of Senator Dodd follows:] PREPARED STATEMENT OF SENATOR CHRISTOPHER J. DODD, U.S.... |
| 03:05:451 min. |
Dr. TAKEYH
Ash can talk about his buffer plan. I’ll briefly say something that has been alluded to in this hearing and others—is to, I always view... |
| 03:07:3015 sec. |
Mr. CARTER
Before my Security Officer has a stroke, I would say that I would have to ask, and I would probably not be allowed to go. |
| 03:07:455 sec. |
The CHAIRMAN
But it might be important to publicize the fact that you are attempting to do that. |
| 03:07:501 min. |
Dr. TAKEYH
Simon and I went through months of negotiations to go and they never, ultimately their final response was a no re- VerDate 11-MAY-2000 13:50... |
| 03:09:00 |
The CHAIRMAN
Ash, do you have a thought? |
| 03:09:001 min. |
Mr. CARTER
Just two observations here, both excellent questions, and Ray has given excellent answers to them. On the question of the troops in the... |
| 03:10:402 min. |
Mr. INDYK
I would just say, first of all, on the issue of exchanges, I think, in principle, it’s a very good idea, and we should encourage it, but... |
| 03:12:4854 sec. |
The CHAIRMAN
Well, there is lots of optimism. That’s a lot of wisdom, and we appreciate it very much—your thoughtfulness, your patience, your stamina,... |