Text Timeline
  • Text Timeline
  • Graphical Timeline
00:00:419 sec.
Lamb, Brian - Host

Abigail Thernstrom, co-author of "No Excuses: Closing the Racial Gap in Learning," what`s the reason that you decided to do this book?

00:00:5040 sec.
Thernstrom, Abigail - Commissioner

Well, we decided to do the book because the racial gap is, it seems to us, the domestic problem. Education continues, of course, in the eyes of most...

00:01:301 sec.
Lamb, Brian - Host

How wide is the gap?

00:01:3134 sec.
Thernstrom, Abigail - Commissioner

The gap is appalling. At the end of high school, the typical African-American or Latino student is about four years behind -- depends on the subject...

00:02:0539 sec.
Thernstrom, Abigail - Commissioner

Our best source of information is the National Assessment for Educational Progress. It`s the nation`s report card on education. It`s called NAPE, and...

00:02:4424 sec.
Thernstrom, Abigail - Commissioner

I could go on with numbers. I mean, look, the majority of black students -- NAPE has got seven tests. On five of them, majority of black students fall...

00:03:0845 sec.
Thernstrom, Abigail - Commissioner

And if you look -- if you look at the top -- students at the very top, instead of looking at the below basic -- the top category is advanced -- and...

00:03:5312 sec.
Lamb, Brian - Host

You have some statistics in your book: 37 percent of black children live with two parents, 77 percent of white students live with two parents...

00:04:051 sec.
Thernstrom, Abigail - Commissioner

Right.

00:04:069 sec.
Lamb, Brian - Host

... 65 percent of Hispanics live with two parents, and 81 percent of Asians live with two parents. How much does that have to do with it?

00:04:151 min.
Thernstrom, Abigail - Commissioner

It does make a difference. There are strong correlations between single-parent households, birth to a young mother, parental education, place of residence...

00:05:2026 sec.
Thernstrom, Abigail - Commissioner

But nevertheless, all of these factors do have something to do with academic achievement, but they explain only about a third of the gap, so that you`re...

00:05:465 sec.
Lamb, Brian - Host

I think it`s safe to assume that you are enamored by somebody by the name of Esquith.

00:05:512 sec.
Thernstrom, Abigail - Commissioner

Yes. A teacher.

00:05:531 sec.
Lamb, Brian - Host

Full name?

00:05:542 sec.
Thernstrom, Abigail - Commissioner

Rafe Esquith.

00:05:561 sec.
Lamb, Brian - Host

Where does he live?

00:05:571 sec.
Thernstrom, Abigail - Commissioner

In Los Angeles.

00:05:581 sec.
Lamb, Brian - Host

What does he do?

00:05:5958 sec.
Thernstrom, Abigail - Commissioner

Well, he, in effect, runs a one-room schoolhouse in a -- though the principal of the school would not like it to be described as such -- in a very large...

00:06:5731 sec.
Thernstrom, Abigail - Commissioner

You have to be a kind of crazy man, like he is -- in the best sense -- to get away with what he does. He is there -- it`s become a little later now,...

00:07:2852 sec.
Thernstrom, Abigail - Commissioner

And after school, this school has almost no sports. He`s got -- he`s got phys ed for his kids, but he also has something called the Hobart Shakespeareans....

00:08:2033 sec.
Thernstrom, Abigail - Commissioner

I mean, I went several times during the year two years ago, to see his "King Lear" develop and to see the kids start out, you know, line by line, talking...

00:08:5326 sec.
Thernstrom, Abigail - Commissioner

And I had called my husband, Stephan, who is my co-author on this book. I had called him after I first saw the kids reading "Lear." I had called him...

00:09:1946 sec.
Thernstrom, Abigail - Commissioner

Rafe has done a wonderful job, but he`s not interested in running a school. Nobody copies him in the school. Nobody pays attention to him. I went to...

00:10:0521 sec.
Thernstrom, Abigail - Commissioner

He`s there working with his kids on Saturday morning. His kids come to his house on Saturdays, and they work on the music for it. Everybody -- everybody...

00:10:2634 sec.
Thernstrom, Abigail - Commissioner

But he does more than teach, and this is true of all the schools that we talk about. They do more than teach reading, writing and arithmetic. They do...

00:11:0045 sec.
Thernstrom, Abigail - Commissioner

I just got a Christmas card from one of the children he has. Every child in his class writes a Christmas card to somebody who has been to the class...

00:11:456 sec.
Lamb, Brian - Host

Do you have to volunteer for the class? How do you get in it?

00:11:5121 sec.
Thernstrom, Abigail - Commissioner

You get -- the school assigns you, but there are a lot of kids who have joined the Shakespeare production in 4th grade and really campaign to get in...

00:12:122 sec.
Lamb, Brian - Host

It`s called Hobart?

00:12:141 sec.
Thernstrom, Abigail - Commissioner

Hobart Elementary School.

00:12:152 sec.
Lamb, Brian - Host

Elementary school. And it`s located where?

00:12:174 sec.
Thernstrom, Abigail - Commissioner

In central Los Angeles. It`s really Koreatown.

00:12:213 sec.
Lamb, Brian - Host

And Rafe Esquith is how old?

00:12:244 sec.
Thernstrom, Abigail - Commissioner

Rafe has got to be mid-40s now.

00:12:281 sec.
Lamb, Brian - Host

How long has been doing this?

00:12:2920 sec.
Thernstrom, Abigail - Commissioner

Since college. Well, no, he`s been teaching since college. He`s -- well, he`s been doing this, though, for -- well, he started out in an affluent school,...

00:12:493 sec.
Lamb, Brian - Host

So what happens to these kids after they leave the 5th grade?

00:12:5242 sec.
Thernstrom, Abigail - Commissioner

Well, he keeps track of them. He has SAT preparation. And by the way, he does a lot of testing preparation in the classroom. And he has the kids get...

00:13:342 sec.
Lamb, Brian - Host

Who gives him money?

00:13:3618 sec.
Thernstrom, Abigail - Commissioner

Various benefactors who are enamored with his class. He`s -- I mean, he`s very good at advertising his -- what he`s doing, and that`s a special skill...

00:13:542 sec.
Lamb, Brian - Host

Does he personally benefit from this?

00:13:562 sec.
Thernstrom, Abigail - Commissioner

No. No.

00:13:581 sec.
Lamb, Brian - Host

He doesn`t make any more than any other teacher?

00:13:5956 sec.
Thernstrom, Abigail - Commissioner

No, he makes less than other teachers because -- well, for a number of reasons. One, he`s refused to get these Mickey-Mouse, meaningless degrees that...

00:14:5521 sec.
Thernstrom, Abigail - Commissioner

But I mean, one of the arguments I make -- or we make in the book, I should say -- and it happens to -- I`m the one who visited all the schools, so...

00:15:165 sec.
Lamb, Brian - Host

Let me ask you -- it might sound like an odd question. If Mary Frances Berry read this book...

00:15:211 sec.
Thernstrom, Abigail - Commissioner

Did she?

00:15:221 sec.
Lamb, Brian - Host

I say, If she read it.

00:15:233 sec.
Thernstrom, Abigail - Commissioner

Oh, if she read it. I was going to say, you have more news I don`t have.

00:15:266 sec.
Lamb, Brian - Host

Yes. You two have tangled, Civil Rights Commission, she`s the chairman, you`re a member. How long have you been a member of the Civil Rights Commission?

00:15:323 sec.
Thernstrom, Abigail - Commissioner

Since January of 2001.

00:15:352 sec.
Lamb, Brian - Host

And what is it, by the way? What does it do?

00:15:3732 sec.
Thernstrom, Abigail - Commissioner

It`s a federal agency. It was created in 1957 in the `57 Civil Rights Act to monitor Civil Rights, write reports -- monitor the state of Civil Rights,...

00:16:0914 sec.
Lamb, Brian - Host

And the reason I asked the question that way, Mary Frances Berry, the chairman, is an African-American. And I just -- from your experience and knowing...

00:16:2358 sec.
Thernstrom, Abigail - Commissioner

I think what she would strongly disagree with -- I`m not sure what she would agree with, but what she would strongly disagree with is a -- is our skepticism...

00:17:2112 sec.
Lamb, Brian - Host

If you were to put your finger on the one -- I know there`s more than one -- the one thing, the biggest thing that has caused difficulty for -- in this...

00:17:3324 sec.
Thernstrom, Abigail - Commissioner

I`d prefer, of course, not to say one thing, but if I had to say one thing, it`s that there is a radical disconnect from the world of academic achievement...

00:17:571 sec.
Lamb, Brian - Host

Why is there a disconnect?

00:17:581 min.
Thernstrom, Abigail - Commissioner

Well, I don`t think we can completely answer that question. But we can say a couple of obviousy things, like education traditionally in this country,...

00:19:0234 sec.
Thernstrom, Abigail - Commissioner

That is true today. I mean, equal skills and knowledge -- not equal years spending -- warming a seat in a classroom, but actual skills and knowledge,...

00:19:362 sec.
Lamb, Brian - Host

Do you live in Cambridge, Massachusetts?

00:19:381 sec.
Thernstrom, Abigail - Commissioner

I don`t. I live in Lexington.

00:19:394 sec.
Lamb, Brian - Host

Lexington is right near Cambridge, though. Cambridge is where Harvard is.

00:19:432 sec.
Thernstrom, Abigail - Commissioner

My husband teaches at Harvard.

00:19:4511 sec.
Lamb, Brian - Host

Yes. The reason I bring this up is -- did I read it right that in Cambridge, Massachusetts, they spend $17,000 per student, and the national average...

00:19:561 sec.
Thernstrom, Abigail - Commissioner

Yes, you read it right.

00:19:573 sec.
Lamb, Brian - Host

The highest amount of money spent anywhere in the country.

00:20:002 sec.
Thernstrom, Abigail - Commissioner

I don`t know if it`s actually the highest, but it`s up there.

00:20:022 sec.
Lamb, Brian - Host

What`s the racial mix of Cambridge?

00:20:0437 sec.
Thernstrom, Abigail - Commissioner

Oh, it`s got a substantial black population. I can`t -- and a substantial Hispanic population. I can`t remember precisely the numbers at the moment,...

00:20:413 sec.
Lamb, Brian - Host

What`s the moral pedestal?

00:20:4417 sec.
Thernstrom, Abigail - Commissioner

Oh, moral pedestal -- Cambridge thinks that it`s full of progressive ideas about education and progressive ideas about equality. And in fact, it`s not...

00:21:012 sec.
Lamb, Brian - Host

Does anybody acknowledge that?

00:21:031 min.
Thernstrom, Abigail - Commissioner

Well, we do have a quotation in the book from the superintendent, saying, yes, I know we got to do something about it. But the fact is, they aren`t...

00:22:163 sec.
Lamb, Brian - Host

KIPP -- K-I-P-P -- stands for what?

00:22:192 sec.
Thernstrom, Abigail - Commissioner

Knowledge Is Power Program.

00:22:2111 sec.
Lamb, Brian - Host

I understand there`s something called the Key Academy right here in Washington, but you talk about a KIPP school in Houston, among others. How many...

00:22:3221 sec.
Thernstrom, Abigail - Commissioner

I think they`re up to 32 this year, but I -- that could be slightly high. In any case, they`ve got -- I think that`s right. They`ve got a big replication...

00:22:531 sec.
Lamb, Brian - Host

What`s it called?

00:22:5411 sec.
Thernstrom, Abigail - Commissioner

It was just called KIPP Academy because, you see, the first two schools were the only KIPPs, so it was KIPP New York and KIPP Houston. This was -- the...

00:23:053 sec.
Lamb, Brian - Host

When did they start it?

00:23:083 sec.
Thernstrom, Abigail - Commissioner

Let me see, about three years ago now. Something like that.

00:23:111 sec.
Lamb, Brian - Host

Who started it?

00:23:126 sec.
Thernstrom, Abigail - Commissioner

It`s the Fisher Foundation, which is Gap money, and...

00:23:181 sec.
Lamb, Brian - Host

What`s Gap money?

00:23:196 sec.
Thernstrom, Abigail - Commissioner

The clothes you wear. Or some people wear, anyway. Maybe you don`t.

00:23:255 sec.
Lamb, Brian - Host

Anybody in particular behind that? I mean, any people that are running that whole operation?

00:23:3031 sec.
Thernstrom, Abigail - Commissioner

Yes. They`ve got -- you know, they hired a staff, and Mike Feinberg actually -- it`s run out of San Francisco -- has just left there and gone back to...

00:24:0130 sec.
Thernstrom, Abigail - Commissioner

I mean, I should say, this is an incredible story because Feinberg and Levin -- University of Pennsylvania graduate, Yale graduate, Levin was -- and...

00:24:3141 sec.
Thernstrom, Abigail - Commissioner

And so they started a school in Houston. And after a year, Dave went to New York and started the school only on one floor of a school that has three...

00:25:1252 sec.
Thernstrom, Abigail - Commissioner

When he arrived, he said -- when he managed to persuade the New York City authorities to let him try this, he said, But you`re not sending me teachers...

00:26:042 sec.
Lamb, Brian - Host

Is this a public school, by the way?

00:26:0619 sec.
Thernstrom, Abigail - Commissioner

For five years, it was a regular public school, and now it`s become a charter school, which turned out to be essential. He needed the autonomy and the...

00:26:2534 sec.
Thernstrom, Abigail - Commissioner

I mean, I was with him for a day. He was up in Massachusetts. I was with him for a day, which I really wanted to talk to him, and he spent the day arguing...

00:26:5914 sec.
Lamb, Brian - Host

Let me ask you, though, to define what a charter school is. I think you say in your book that there`s 36 states that have charter schools in them, and...

00:27:1321 sec.
Thernstrom, Abigail - Commissioner

They are public schools. They`re often -- people refer to public schools and then charter schools. No. Charter schools are public schools. But they...

00:27:3436 sec.
Thernstrom, Abigail - Commissioner

In Massachusetts, where I`m on the state board of education, it is the state board that charters the schools, gives a charter to a group that comes...

00:28:1013 sec.
Thernstrom, Abigail - Commissioner

So the accountability is attached to freedom. Yes, you have the freedom. You`re out from under the collective bargaining agreements -- very, very important.

00:28:232 sec.
Lamb, Brian - Host

You don`t belong to a union?

00:28:251 sec.
Thernstrom, Abigail - Commissioner

No.

00:28:262 sec.
Lamb, Brian - Host

The teachers do not belong to a union?

00:28:28
Thernstrom, Abigail - Commissioner

That`s correct.

00:28:282 sec.
Lamb, Brian - Host

They cannot -- or the unions -- can the unions organize them?

00:28:301 sec.
Thernstrom, Abigail - Commissioner

No.

00:28:311 sec.
Lamb, Brian - Host

Under what law?

00:28:3216 sec.
Thernstrom, Abigail - Commissioner

Well, I mean, that`s part of the charter school that these schools are free to be non-union. I mean, can it -- no, the unions wouldn`t try because these...

00:28:482 sec.
Lamb, Brian - Host

Do they make more or less than a normal public school?

00:28:5030 sec.
Thernstrom, Abigail - Commissioner

They are -- the charter schools in general, by the way, have smaller budgets, although they can supplement them by fund-raising. But they have smaller...

00:29:2046 sec.
Thernstrom, Abigail - Commissioner

But in any case, you know, what`s important about the teacher pay that they have differential salaries, by and large. That is, the good teachers get...

00:30:0610 sec.
Thernstrom, Abigail - Commissioner

Now, they do get extra pay for the long hours, for instance, that the KIPP teachers spend, and that money has to be raised.

00:30:1613 sec.
Lamb, Brian - Host

There are 2,700 charter schools in 36 states and the District of Columbia. Is there any evidence that the charter schools either graduate more kids?...

00:30:2946 sec.
Thernstrom, Abigail - Commissioner

Too much variety in the quality of the charter schools. In some states, you`ve got -- I mean -- Arizona has got more charter schools than I can count....

00:31:155 sec.
Lamb, Brian - Host

If I live in a community and there`s a charter school and I`m middle or high school, can I go to one?

00:31:204 sec.
Thernstrom, Abigail - Commissioner

Well, you can try to go to one. But, I mean, all these charter schools have huge waiting lists.

00:31:242 sec.
Lamb, Brian - Host

Who decides who gets in?

00:31:261 sec.
Thernstrom, Abigail - Commissioner

Random selection.

00:31:272 sec.
Lamb, Brian - Host

Random meaning ...

00:31:291 sec.
Thernstrom, Abigail - Commissioner

Put your ...

00:31:301 sec.
Lamb, Brian - Host

Lottery?

00:31:311 sec.
Thernstrom, Abigail - Commissioner

Yeah, lottery.

00:31:324 sec.
Lamb, Brian - Host

So it`s not -- is it decided on race or -- is it -- no quotas or anything like that?

00:31:3616 sec.
Thernstrom, Abigail - Commissioner

No. And in fact, the charters -- all the charter schools that we talk about in the book are -- well, Ray`s class has got some -- obviously got Korean...

00:31:5226 sec.
Lamb, Brian - Host

Why is it that all your statistics show that almost in every category, Asians, and they`re 4 percent of the American public school students are Asian....

00:32:1849 sec.
Thernstrom, Abigail - Commissioner

Culture matters. That is the toughest message we`ve got in the book. And it`s the message we thought that people were going to have a hard time swallowing....

00:33:072 sec.
Lamb, Brian - Host

What do we mean by culture?

00:33:0914 sec.
Thernstrom, Abigail - Commissioner

And that`s a very important question, because we hesitated, Steve and I, about using the word culture, because it`s got baggage. It has the implication...

00:33:2347 sec.
Thernstrom, Abigail - Commissioner

And what we simply mean by culture is those values and skills that are shaped and reshaped by environment. Nothing permanent about it. But that nevertheless,...

00:34:1017 sec.
Thernstrom, Abigail - Commissioner

Asian culture by and large -- we`re talking about averages here. But what`s interesting is that of course when we use the umbrella word Asian, you`re...

00:34:276 sec.
Lamb, Brian - Host

I mean, you point out Pacific Islanders, who are Asian, don`t do as well as others.

00:34:3336 sec.
Thernstrom, Abigail - Commissioner

Don`t do as well. But by and large, just looking at averages, Asians do do spectacularly well in school, much better than whites in some respects. And...

00:35:097 sec.
Lamb, Brian - Host

But you go back to the statistics again, 81 percent of Asian students have two parents in the home.

00:35:161 sec.
Thernstrom, Abigail - Commissioner

It matters.

00:35:174 sec.
Lamb, Brian - Host

And 77 percent of black kids have only one parent in the home.

00:35:2116 sec.
Thernstrom, Abigail - Commissioner

That matters. But it unfortunately -- I mean, there is very good statistical work on this. It explains about a third of the gap -- well, all the demographic...

00:35:372 sec.
Lamb, Brian - Host

Go to TV. You write about television.

00:35:391 sec.
Thernstrom, Abigail - Commissioner

Yes.

00:35:409 sec.
Lamb, Brian - Host

Blacks watch on average -- kids, five hours of television a day, an hour more than white kids do. And a lot more than Asian kids do. How much does that...

00:35:4932 sec.
Thernstrom, Abigail - Commissioner

No, actually you have -- unless my memory doesn`t serve me correctly, the whites and Asians mysteriously don`t look that much different, and the black...

00:36:217 sec.
Lamb, Brian - Host

Stop there for a second. Define that phrase. You used it several times, social homework. What is it?

00:36:2816 sec.
Thernstrom, Abigail - Commissioner

It`s what they need to do to be socially acceptable to their peers, to be part of the group. Every teenager, every kid wants to be accepted by his or...

00:36:444 sec.
Lamb, Brian - Host

How much does that have to do with the parent not being there saying turn that off?

00:36:4833 sec.
Thernstrom, Abigail - Commissioner

That has something to do with it, but it also has to do obviously with -- well, it does have something to do with it. But I was going to say it also...

00:37:2115 sec.
Thernstrom, Abigail - Commissioner

So either they`re exaggerating the amount of television in order to feel that they sound American, or they`re putting television in the background and...

00:37:3629 sec.
Thernstrom, Abigail - Commissioner

But look, the extraordinary thing about Asians is not simply that their parents deliver the message, but that they listen to their parents. And we have...

00:38:057 sec.
Thernstrom, Abigail - Commissioner

And we also have -- you mentioned the Key academy, which is a KIPP Academy...

00:38:121 sec.
Lamb, Brian - Host

Here in Washington.

00:38:1332 sec.
Thernstrom, Abigail - Commissioner

Here in Washington, D.C., where the director of the Key has to say to a mother, you are not your child`s friend. Your child needs a mother. So it`s...

00:38:4527 sec.
Thernstrom, Abigail - Commissioner

I think inner city blacks are much more depressed about -- and that`s important, about what the possibilities are for them and their kids, and it is...

00:39:1242 sec.
Lamb, Brian - Host

Let me ask you this, then, because you have got 2001 statistics on the freshmen class in the following colleges and the percentage of the freshman class...

00:39:541 min.
Thernstrom, Abigail - Commissioner

Yes, and there are murmurings of that sort, and you left out the California system, Asians are 4 percent of the American population, they`re 10 percent...

00:41:149 sec.
Lamb, Brian - Host

On the back of your book, I want to mention who you have endorsing. This is praise for "American Black and White," which is another book.

00:41:232 sec.
Thernstrom, Abigail - Commissioner

Right. I was just going to say, don`t mix that up.

00:41:2514 sec.
Lamb, Brian - Host

No, I`m not. But I was interested in this. Linda Chavez, Tom Sowell, Shelby Steele, Alan Wolfe, James P. Wilson. And Henry Louis Gates. How did you...

00:41:3938 sec.
Thernstrom, Abigail - Commissioner

He read it, and he said, by God, you`ve got a good book here. And, you know, we`re extremely grateful to him. He`s intellectually willing to read books,...

00:42:1719 sec.
Lamb, Brian - Host

How often does it happen because you`re the authors, you and your husband Stephan are the authors of a book like this, that a lot of people in education,...

00:42:361 min.
Thernstrom, Abigail - Commissioner

It`s happened less with this book than with "American Black and White," and I can`t quite figure out why. And indeed our agents say, more controversy,...

00:43:464 sec.
Lamb, Brian - Host

The title of your book is "No Excuses." Where does that come from?

00:43:5060 sec.
Thernstrom, Abigail - Commissioner

Well, the schools we describe are often called no-excuses schools. And that predated the title of this book. But we have a larger meaning to it. We...

00:44:5051 sec.
Thernstrom, Abigail - Commissioner

So no excuses to the school, no excuses to the teachers. It`s responsibility all around here. No excuses to the kids, no excuses to the parents who...

00:45:414 sec.
Lamb, Brian - Host

How long have you and Stephan Thernstrom been married?

00:45:454 sec.
Thernstrom, Abigail - Commissioner

It will be 45 years in -- this January 3.

00:45:491 sec.
Lamb, Brian - Host

Where did you meet?

00:45:501 sec.
Thernstrom, Abigail - Commissioner

At Harvard graduate school.

00:45:512 sec.
Lamb, Brian - Host

Studying what?

00:45:5328 sec.
Thernstrom, Abigail - Commissioner

He was studying American history. Actually, in the program on degrees in American civilization, and at the time I was studying, if you can believe it,...

00:46:211 sec.
Lamb, Brian - Host

Where?

00:46:2243 sec.
Thernstrom, Abigail - Commissioner

Croton-on-Hudson, New York, which was known at the time for a lot of members of the American Communist Party and fellow travelers. And it was a very...

00:47:053 sec.
Lamb, Brian - Host

Where is he from? Meaning your husband, Stephan?

00:47:0819 sec.
Thernstrom, Abigail - Commissioner

He is from Battle Creek, Michigan, and before that, Port Huron, Michigan. Very, very different family than mine. My family in my teens moved to New...

00:47:271 sec.
Lamb, Brian - Host

Have you had children?

00:47:281 sec.
Thernstrom, Abigail - Commissioner

Two children, yes.

00:47:291 sec.
Lamb, Brian - Host

How old are they today?

00:47:302 sec.
Thernstrom, Abigail - Commissioner

36 and 39.

00:47:322 sec.
Lamb, Brian - Host

What kind of schools did they go to?

00:47:3412 sec.
Thernstrom, Abigail - Commissioner

They went to public schools in Lexington. Well, public schools in Los Angeles and then Lexington. Steve was teaching at UCLA for a while. And then they...

00:47:461 sec.
Lamb, Brian - Host

Have you ever taught?

00:47:473 sec.
Thernstrom, Abigail - Commissioner

Yes, at Harvard, I have.

00:47:501 sec.
Lamb, Brian - Host

For how long?

00:47:5139 sec.
Thernstrom, Abigail - Commissioner

Let me see, I had a lectureship for three years and then we went to England for a year. I gave it up. And then I came back on a visiting basis to teach...

00:48:3032 sec.
Lamb, Brian - Host

Take this book and what you`ve learned in all your studies and put yourself in the District of Columbia, where I think they spend as much as $15,000...

00:49:0212 sec.
Thernstrom, Abigail - Commissioner

Well, of course, D.C. has a potential voucher program on the table, and I would really push.

00:49:145 sec.
Lamb, Brian - Host

Let`s say no vouchers yet and you want to do something right now?

00:49:1938 sec.
Thernstrom, Abigail - Commissioner

Well, you`ve got to support your kid and you`ve got to scream bloody murder in the local school if you don`t think your kid is being properly taken...

00:49:5724 sec.
Thernstrom, Abigail - Commissioner

Any child that`s not reading by third grade, bells of alarm should go off in a parent`s head as well as teachers, instead of oh, well, he or she will...

00:50:2113 sec.
Lamb, Brian - Host

Yeah, but say again, you don`t really know what it is that should be expected of a child. I mean, how -- you are implying here that if you haven`t learned...

00:50:3418 sec.
Thernstrom, Abigail - Commissioner

Yeah. Though I would say there is -- I mean, KIPP schools, remember, are middle schools, and there are some high schools that are turning kids` lives...

00:50:5237 sec.
Thernstrom, Abigail - Commissioner

Look, you do the best you can to deliver the message to your kid that this is a country with its arms wide open for young people with skills and talent....

00:51:2917 sec.
Lamb, Brian - Host

What if you`re not a reader? What if you just have an instinct, I want my kid to be the best and have the best education, and you`re just -- you know,...

00:51:4640 sec.
Thernstrom, Abigail - Commissioner

Well, in many cities -- I don`t actually know the D.C. scene, but there are a lot of privately funded scholarships that do get children out of the regular...

00:52:2615 sec.
Lamb, Brian - Host

What would you do with your child when it comes to the social homework that`s so important? I mean, you go so far in here as to talk about not allowing...

00:52:4123 sec.
Thernstrom, Abigail - Commissioner

The school has to not allow it. The parents can`t assume that burden all alone. Look, you asked where did we meet, do we have children and all that,...

00:53:0437 sec.
Thernstrom, Abigail - Commissioner

My kids watched very little television, because they had these terrible parents. They were allowed to watch on Saturday mornings, but by the time they...

00:53:4117 sec.
Thernstrom, Abigail - Commissioner

It`s hard to do that to your kids. And I`m not sure my kids would do that to their kids. So there are tradeoffs, but, you know, you`ve got to keep your...

00:53:581 sec.
Lamb, Brian - Host

Were your parents educated?

00:53:591 sec.
Thernstrom, Abigail - Commissioner

Yes, they were.

00:54:002 sec.
Lamb, Brian - Host

How many degrees?

00:54:0217 sec.
Thernstrom, Abigail - Commissioner

Well, my father, just short of a college degree, and my mother -- and the reason I`m hesitating is my mother died when I was fairly young. I think that...

00:54:192 sec.
Lamb, Brian - Host

Were there books in your both of your families?

00:54:2127 sec.
Thernstrom, Abigail - Commissioner

Books in my family, yes. In his family, yes, to some extent, even though his mother was only a high school graduate and, again, his father only eighth...

00:54:4851 sec.
Thernstrom, Abigail - Commissioner

Steve was thrilled when we wrote an article for "Reader`s Digest," because it had been his father`s education. And -- but Steve was a total delinquent...

00:55:393 sec.
Lamb, Brian - Host

So you -- both of you have got Harvard degrees?

00:55:422 sec.
Thernstrom, Abigail - Commissioner

I`m not undergraduate.

00:55:441 sec.
Lamb, Brian - Host

But Ph.D.`s?

00:55:451 sec.
Thernstrom, Abigail - Commissioner

Ph.D.`s, yes.

00:55:462 sec.
Lamb, Brian - Host

And both of your kids have Harvard degrees?

00:55:481 sec.
Thernstrom, Abigail - Commissioner

Yes.

00:55:497 sec.
Lamb, Brian - Host

You can imagine people saying, how could she possibly know the problems of an inner city school.

00:55:5630 sec.
Thernstrom, Abigail - Commissioner

I don`t know all the problems of an inner city school, but I am an American. I`m part of the society. I`ve had a -- I`ve been writing on issues of race...

00:56:267 sec.
Lamb, Brian - Host

Why is the right wing upset about this book and think that it`s an I.Q. problem?

00:56:3348 sec.
Thernstrom, Abigail - Commissioner

Well, I just said some. The flak we`ve gotten, interestingly enough, has been less from the left than -- well, there is -- look, there are a lot of...

00:57:214 sec.
Lamb, Brian - Host

I.Q., intelligence coefficient or intelligence quotient...

00:57:251 sec.
Thernstrom, Abigail - Commissioner

Quotient.

00:57:262 sec.
Lamb, Brian - Host

Quotient. And do you know what yours is?

00:57:283 sec.
Thernstrom, Abigail - Commissioner

No. And I don`t know what his is either.

00:57:315 sec.
Lamb, Brian - Host

But do people know -- I mean, how do we know? Who knows what someone`s I.Q. is?

00:57:368 sec.
Thernstrom, Abigail - Commissioner

I don`t know, but there`s a certain amount of -- a certain amount of I.Q. testing and social affairs, you know...

00:57:442 sec.
Lamb, Brian - Host

Do they still do it in schools?

00:57:4620 sec.
Thernstrom, Abigail - Commissioner

... there`s literature. That`s a very good question that I don`t know the answer to. I`ve asked it with the schools that we`ve looked at, have looked...

00:58:066 sec.
Lamb, Brian - Host

I have got to ask this, just as we get near the end, are you glad that you went on the Civil Rights Commission?

00:58:1230 sec.
Thernstrom, Abigail - Commissioner

Yes, I am. I am glad because I -- because race remains, as I said at the very beginning of this interview, it remains the American dilemma. You know,...

00:58:429 sec.
Lamb, Brian - Host

How much of what we see on our C-SPAN television screens when we cover the commissions between you and Mary Frances Berry is personal and how much of...

00:58:514 sec.
Thernstrom, Abigail - Commissioner

The personal is the political for her.

00:58:552 sec.
Lamb, Brian - Host

What does that mean?

00:58:5719 sec.
Thernstrom, Abigail - Commissioner

She can`t separate the two. She can`t separate the two. I really believe that I can totally. I have all sorts of friends whom I really disagree with...

00:59:1613 sec.
Lamb, Brian - Host

This is the cover of the book. Our guest has been the co-author, Abigail Thernstrom, with her husband, Stephan Thernstrom, and the title of this book...

00:59:2949 sec.
Thernstrom, Abigail - Commissioner

Thank you for having me, Brian.

Loading...