| 00:00:419 sec. |
Lamb, Brian - Host
Abigail Thernstrom, co-author of "No Excuses: Closing the Racial Gap in Learning," what`s the reason that you decided to do this book? |
| 00:00:5040 sec. |
Thernstrom, Abigail - Commissioner
Well, we decided to do the book because the racial gap is, it seems to us, the domestic problem. Education continues, of course, in the eyes of most... |
| 00:01:301 sec. |
Lamb, Brian - Host
How wide is the gap? |
| 00:01:3134 sec. |
Thernstrom, Abigail - Commissioner
The gap is appalling. At the end of high school, the typical African-American or Latino student is about four years behind -- depends on the subject... |
| 00:02:0539 sec. |
Thernstrom, Abigail - Commissioner
Our best source of information is the National Assessment for Educational Progress. It`s the nation`s report card on education. It`s called NAPE, and... |
| 00:02:4424 sec. |
Thernstrom, Abigail - Commissioner
I could go on with numbers. I mean, look, the majority of black students -- NAPE has got seven tests. On five of them, majority of black students fall... |
| 00:03:0845 sec. |
Thernstrom, Abigail - Commissioner
And if you look -- if you look at the top -- students at the very top, instead of looking at the below basic -- the top category is advanced -- and... |
| 00:03:5312 sec. |
Lamb, Brian - Host
You have some statistics in your book: 37 percent of black children live with two parents, 77 percent of white students live with two parents... |
| 00:04:051 sec. |
Thernstrom, Abigail - Commissioner
Right. |
| 00:04:069 sec. |
Lamb, Brian - Host
... 65 percent of Hispanics live with two parents, and 81 percent of Asians live with two parents. How much does that have to do with it? |
| 00:04:151 min. |
Thernstrom, Abigail - Commissioner
It does make a difference. There are strong correlations between single-parent households, birth to a young mother, parental education, place of residence... |
| 00:05:2026 sec. |
Thernstrom, Abigail - Commissioner
But nevertheless, all of these factors do have something to do with academic achievement, but they explain only about a third of the gap, so that you`re... |
| 00:05:465 sec. |
Lamb, Brian - Host
I think it`s safe to assume that you are enamored by somebody by the name of Esquith. |
| 00:05:512 sec. |
Thernstrom, Abigail - Commissioner
Yes. A teacher. |
| 00:05:531 sec. |
Lamb, Brian - Host
Full name? |
| 00:05:542 sec. |
Thernstrom, Abigail - Commissioner
Rafe Esquith. |
| 00:05:561 sec. |
Lamb, Brian - Host
Where does he live? |
| 00:05:571 sec. |
Thernstrom, Abigail - Commissioner
In Los Angeles. |
| 00:05:581 sec. |
Lamb, Brian - Host
What does he do? |
| 00:05:5958 sec. |
Thernstrom, Abigail - Commissioner
Well, he, in effect, runs a one-room schoolhouse in a -- though the principal of the school would not like it to be described as such -- in a very large... |
| 00:06:5731 sec. |
Thernstrom, Abigail - Commissioner
You have to be a kind of crazy man, like he is -- in the best sense -- to get away with what he does. He is there -- it`s become a little later now,... |
| 00:07:2852 sec. |
Thernstrom, Abigail - Commissioner
And after school, this school has almost no sports. He`s got -- he`s got phys ed for his kids, but he also has something called the Hobart Shakespeareans.... |
| 00:08:2033 sec. |
Thernstrom, Abigail - Commissioner
I mean, I went several times during the year two years ago, to see his "King Lear" develop and to see the kids start out, you know, line by line, talking... |
| 00:08:5326 sec. |
Thernstrom, Abigail - Commissioner
And I had called my husband, Stephan, who is my co-author on this book. I had called him after I first saw the kids reading "Lear." I had called him... |
| 00:09:1946 sec. |
Thernstrom, Abigail - Commissioner
Rafe has done a wonderful job, but he`s not interested in running a school. Nobody copies him in the school. Nobody pays attention to him. I went to... |
| 00:10:0521 sec. |
Thernstrom, Abigail - Commissioner
He`s there working with his kids on Saturday morning. His kids come to his house on Saturdays, and they work on the music for it. Everybody -- everybody... |
| 00:10:2634 sec. |
Thernstrom, Abigail - Commissioner
But he does more than teach, and this is true of all the schools that we talk about. They do more than teach reading, writing and arithmetic. They do... |
| 00:11:0045 sec. |
Thernstrom, Abigail - Commissioner
I just got a Christmas card from one of the children he has. Every child in his class writes a Christmas card to somebody who has been to the class... |
| 00:11:456 sec. |
Lamb, Brian - Host
Do you have to volunteer for the class? How do you get in it? |
| 00:11:5121 sec. |
Thernstrom, Abigail - Commissioner
You get -- the school assigns you, but there are a lot of kids who have joined the Shakespeare production in 4th grade and really campaign to get in... |
| 00:12:122 sec. |
Lamb, Brian - Host
It`s called Hobart? |
| 00:12:141 sec. |
Thernstrom, Abigail - Commissioner
Hobart Elementary School. |
| 00:12:152 sec. |
Lamb, Brian - Host
Elementary school. And it`s located where? |
| 00:12:174 sec. |
Thernstrom, Abigail - Commissioner
In central Los Angeles. It`s really Koreatown. |
| 00:12:213 sec. |
Lamb, Brian - Host
And Rafe Esquith is how old? |
| 00:12:244 sec. |
Thernstrom, Abigail - Commissioner
Rafe has got to be mid-40s now. |
| 00:12:281 sec. |
Lamb, Brian - Host
How long has been doing this? |
| 00:12:2920 sec. |
Thernstrom, Abigail - Commissioner
Since college. Well, no, he`s been teaching since college. He`s -- well, he`s been doing this, though, for -- well, he started out in an affluent school,... |
| 00:12:493 sec. |
Lamb, Brian - Host
So what happens to these kids after they leave the 5th grade? |
| 00:12:5242 sec. |
Thernstrom, Abigail - Commissioner
Well, he keeps track of them. He has SAT preparation. And by the way, he does a lot of testing preparation in the classroom. And he has the kids get... |
| 00:13:342 sec. |
Lamb, Brian - Host
Who gives him money? |
| 00:13:3618 sec. |
Thernstrom, Abigail - Commissioner
Various benefactors who are enamored with his class. He`s -- I mean, he`s very good at advertising his -- what he`s doing, and that`s a special skill... |
| 00:13:542 sec. |
Lamb, Brian - Host
Does he personally benefit from this? |
| 00:13:562 sec. |
Thernstrom, Abigail - Commissioner
No. No. |
| 00:13:581 sec. |
Lamb, Brian - Host
He doesn`t make any more than any other teacher? |
| 00:13:5956 sec. |
Thernstrom, Abigail - Commissioner
No, he makes less than other teachers because -- well, for a number of reasons. One, he`s refused to get these Mickey-Mouse, meaningless degrees that... |
| 00:14:5521 sec. |
Thernstrom, Abigail - Commissioner
But I mean, one of the arguments I make -- or we make in the book, I should say -- and it happens to -- I`m the one who visited all the schools, so... |
| 00:15:165 sec. |
Lamb, Brian - Host
Let me ask you -- it might sound like an odd question. If Mary Frances Berry read this book... |
| 00:15:211 sec. |
Thernstrom, Abigail - Commissioner
Did she? |
| 00:15:221 sec. |
Lamb, Brian - Host
I say, If she read it. |
| 00:15:233 sec. |
Thernstrom, Abigail - Commissioner
Oh, if she read it. I was going to say, you have more news I don`t have. |
| 00:15:266 sec. |
Lamb, Brian - Host
Yes. You two have tangled, Civil Rights Commission, she`s the chairman, you`re a member. How long have you been a member of the Civil Rights Commission? |
| 00:15:323 sec. |
Thernstrom, Abigail - Commissioner
Since January of 2001. |
| 00:15:352 sec. |
Lamb, Brian - Host
And what is it, by the way? What does it do? |
| 00:15:3732 sec. |
Thernstrom, Abigail - Commissioner
It`s a federal agency. It was created in 1957 in the `57 Civil Rights Act to monitor Civil Rights, write reports -- monitor the state of Civil Rights,... |
| 00:16:0914 sec. |
Lamb, Brian - Host
And the reason I asked the question that way, Mary Frances Berry, the chairman, is an African-American. And I just -- from your experience and knowing... |
| 00:16:2358 sec. |
Thernstrom, Abigail - Commissioner
I think what she would strongly disagree with -- I`m not sure what she would agree with, but what she would strongly disagree with is a -- is our skepticism... |
| 00:17:2112 sec. |
Lamb, Brian - Host
If you were to put your finger on the one -- I know there`s more than one -- the one thing, the biggest thing that has caused difficulty for -- in this... |
| 00:17:3324 sec. |
Thernstrom, Abigail - Commissioner
I`d prefer, of course, not to say one thing, but if I had to say one thing, it`s that there is a radical disconnect from the world of academic achievement... |
| 00:17:571 sec. |
Lamb, Brian - Host
Why is there a disconnect? |
| 00:17:581 min. |
Thernstrom, Abigail - Commissioner
Well, I don`t think we can completely answer that question. But we can say a couple of obviousy things, like education traditionally in this country,... |
| 00:19:0234 sec. |
Thernstrom, Abigail - Commissioner
That is true today. I mean, equal skills and knowledge -- not equal years spending -- warming a seat in a classroom, but actual skills and knowledge,... |
| 00:19:362 sec. |
Lamb, Brian - Host
Do you live in Cambridge, Massachusetts? |
| 00:19:381 sec. |
Thernstrom, Abigail - Commissioner
I don`t. I live in Lexington. |
| 00:19:394 sec. |
Lamb, Brian - Host
Lexington is right near Cambridge, though. Cambridge is where Harvard is. |
| 00:19:432 sec. |
Thernstrom, Abigail - Commissioner
My husband teaches at Harvard. |
| 00:19:4511 sec. |
Lamb, Brian - Host
Yes. The reason I bring this up is -- did I read it right that in Cambridge, Massachusetts, they spend $17,000 per student, and the national average... |
| 00:19:561 sec. |
Thernstrom, Abigail - Commissioner
Yes, you read it right. |
| 00:19:573 sec. |
Lamb, Brian - Host
The highest amount of money spent anywhere in the country. |
| 00:20:002 sec. |
Thernstrom, Abigail - Commissioner
I don`t know if it`s actually the highest, but it`s up there. |
| 00:20:022 sec. |
Lamb, Brian - Host
What`s the racial mix of Cambridge? |
| 00:20:0437 sec. |
Thernstrom, Abigail - Commissioner
Oh, it`s got a substantial black population. I can`t -- and a substantial Hispanic population. I can`t remember precisely the numbers at the moment,... |
| 00:20:413 sec. |
Lamb, Brian - Host
What`s the moral pedestal? |
| 00:20:4417 sec. |
Thernstrom, Abigail - Commissioner
Oh, moral pedestal -- Cambridge thinks that it`s full of progressive ideas about education and progressive ideas about equality. And in fact, it`s not... |
| 00:21:012 sec. |
Lamb, Brian - Host
Does anybody acknowledge that? |
| 00:21:031 min. |
Thernstrom, Abigail - Commissioner
Well, we do have a quotation in the book from the superintendent, saying, yes, I know we got to do something about it. But the fact is, they aren`t... |
| 00:22:163 sec. |
Lamb, Brian - Host
KIPP -- K-I-P-P -- stands for what? |
| 00:22:192 sec. |
Thernstrom, Abigail - Commissioner
Knowledge Is Power Program. |
| 00:22:2111 sec. |
Lamb, Brian - Host
I understand there`s something called the Key Academy right here in Washington, but you talk about a KIPP school in Houston, among others. How many... |
| 00:22:3221 sec. |
Thernstrom, Abigail - Commissioner
I think they`re up to 32 this year, but I -- that could be slightly high. In any case, they`ve got -- I think that`s right. They`ve got a big replication... |
| 00:22:531 sec. |
Lamb, Brian - Host
What`s it called? |
| 00:22:5411 sec. |
Thernstrom, Abigail - Commissioner
It was just called KIPP Academy because, you see, the first two schools were the only KIPPs, so it was KIPP New York and KIPP Houston. This was -- the... |
| 00:23:053 sec. |
Lamb, Brian - Host
When did they start it? |
| 00:23:083 sec. |
Thernstrom, Abigail - Commissioner
Let me see, about three years ago now. Something like that. |
| 00:23:111 sec. |
Lamb, Brian - Host
Who started it? |
| 00:23:126 sec. |
Thernstrom, Abigail - Commissioner
It`s the Fisher Foundation, which is Gap money, and... |
| 00:23:181 sec. |
Lamb, Brian - Host
What`s Gap money? |
| 00:23:196 sec. |
Thernstrom, Abigail - Commissioner
The clothes you wear. Or some people wear, anyway. Maybe you don`t. |
| 00:23:255 sec. |
Lamb, Brian - Host
Anybody in particular behind that? I mean, any people that are running that whole operation? |
| 00:23:3031 sec. |
Thernstrom, Abigail - Commissioner
Yes. They`ve got -- you know, they hired a staff, and Mike Feinberg actually -- it`s run out of San Francisco -- has just left there and gone back to... |
| 00:24:0130 sec. |
Thernstrom, Abigail - Commissioner
I mean, I should say, this is an incredible story because Feinberg and Levin -- University of Pennsylvania graduate, Yale graduate, Levin was -- and... |
| 00:24:3141 sec. |
Thernstrom, Abigail - Commissioner
And so they started a school in Houston. And after a year, Dave went to New York and started the school only on one floor of a school that has three... |
| 00:25:1252 sec. |
Thernstrom, Abigail - Commissioner
When he arrived, he said -- when he managed to persuade the New York City authorities to let him try this, he said, But you`re not sending me teachers... |
| 00:26:042 sec. |
Lamb, Brian - Host
Is this a public school, by the way? |
| 00:26:0619 sec. |
Thernstrom, Abigail - Commissioner
For five years, it was a regular public school, and now it`s become a charter school, which turned out to be essential. He needed the autonomy and the... |
| 00:26:2534 sec. |
Thernstrom, Abigail - Commissioner
I mean, I was with him for a day. He was up in Massachusetts. I was with him for a day, which I really wanted to talk to him, and he spent the day arguing... |
| 00:26:5914 sec. |
Lamb, Brian - Host
Let me ask you, though, to define what a charter school is. I think you say in your book that there`s 36 states that have charter schools in them, and... |
| 00:27:1321 sec. |
Thernstrom, Abigail - Commissioner
They are public schools. They`re often -- people refer to public schools and then charter schools. No. Charter schools are public schools. But they... |
| 00:27:3436 sec. |
Thernstrom, Abigail - Commissioner
In Massachusetts, where I`m on the state board of education, it is the state board that charters the schools, gives a charter to a group that comes... |
| 00:28:1013 sec. |
Thernstrom, Abigail - Commissioner
So the accountability is attached to freedom. Yes, you have the freedom. You`re out from under the collective bargaining agreements -- very, very important. |
| 00:28:232 sec. |
Lamb, Brian - Host
You don`t belong to a union? |
| 00:28:251 sec. |
Thernstrom, Abigail - Commissioner
No. |
| 00:28:262 sec. |
Lamb, Brian - Host
The teachers do not belong to a union? |
| 00:28:28 |
Thernstrom, Abigail - Commissioner
That`s correct. |
| 00:28:282 sec. |
Lamb, Brian - Host
They cannot -- or the unions -- can the unions organize them? |
| 00:28:301 sec. |
Thernstrom, Abigail - Commissioner
No. |
| 00:28:311 sec. |
Lamb, Brian - Host
Under what law? |
| 00:28:3216 sec. |
Thernstrom, Abigail - Commissioner
Well, I mean, that`s part of the charter school that these schools are free to be non-union. I mean, can it -- no, the unions wouldn`t try because these... |
| 00:28:482 sec. |
Lamb, Brian - Host
Do they make more or less than a normal public school? |
| 00:28:5030 sec. |
Thernstrom, Abigail - Commissioner
They are -- the charter schools in general, by the way, have smaller budgets, although they can supplement them by fund-raising. But they have smaller... |
| 00:29:2046 sec. |
Thernstrom, Abigail - Commissioner
But in any case, you know, what`s important about the teacher pay that they have differential salaries, by and large. That is, the good teachers get... |
| 00:30:0610 sec. |
Thernstrom, Abigail - Commissioner
Now, they do get extra pay for the long hours, for instance, that the KIPP teachers spend, and that money has to be raised. |
| 00:30:1613 sec. |
Lamb, Brian - Host
There are 2,700 charter schools in 36 states and the District of Columbia. Is there any evidence that the charter schools either graduate more kids?... |
| 00:30:2946 sec. |
Thernstrom, Abigail - Commissioner
Too much variety in the quality of the charter schools. In some states, you`ve got -- I mean -- Arizona has got more charter schools than I can count.... |
| 00:31:155 sec. |
Lamb, Brian - Host
If I live in a community and there`s a charter school and I`m middle or high school, can I go to one? |
| 00:31:204 sec. |
Thernstrom, Abigail - Commissioner
Well, you can try to go to one. But, I mean, all these charter schools have huge waiting lists. |
| 00:31:242 sec. |
Lamb, Brian - Host
Who decides who gets in? |
| 00:31:261 sec. |
Thernstrom, Abigail - Commissioner
Random selection. |
| 00:31:272 sec. |
Lamb, Brian - Host
Random meaning ... |
| 00:31:291 sec. |
Thernstrom, Abigail - Commissioner
Put your ... |
| 00:31:301 sec. |
Lamb, Brian - Host
Lottery? |
| 00:31:311 sec. |
Thernstrom, Abigail - Commissioner
Yeah, lottery. |
| 00:31:324 sec. |
Lamb, Brian - Host
So it`s not -- is it decided on race or -- is it -- no quotas or anything like that? |
| 00:31:3616 sec. |
Thernstrom, Abigail - Commissioner
No. And in fact, the charters -- all the charter schools that we talk about in the book are -- well, Ray`s class has got some -- obviously got Korean... |
| 00:31:5226 sec. |
Lamb, Brian - Host
Why is it that all your statistics show that almost in every category, Asians, and they`re 4 percent of the American public school students are Asian.... |
| 00:32:1849 sec. |
Thernstrom, Abigail - Commissioner
Culture matters. That is the toughest message we`ve got in the book. And it`s the message we thought that people were going to have a hard time swallowing.... |
| 00:33:072 sec. |
Lamb, Brian - Host
What do we mean by culture? |
| 00:33:0914 sec. |
Thernstrom, Abigail - Commissioner
And that`s a very important question, because we hesitated, Steve and I, about using the word culture, because it`s got baggage. It has the implication... |
| 00:33:2347 sec. |
Thernstrom, Abigail - Commissioner
And what we simply mean by culture is those values and skills that are shaped and reshaped by environment. Nothing permanent about it. But that nevertheless,... |
| 00:34:1017 sec. |
Thernstrom, Abigail - Commissioner
Asian culture by and large -- we`re talking about averages here. But what`s interesting is that of course when we use the umbrella word Asian, you`re... |
| 00:34:276 sec. |
Lamb, Brian - Host
I mean, you point out Pacific Islanders, who are Asian, don`t do as well as others. |
| 00:34:3336 sec. |
Thernstrom, Abigail - Commissioner
Don`t do as well. But by and large, just looking at averages, Asians do do spectacularly well in school, much better than whites in some respects. And... |
| 00:35:097 sec. |
Lamb, Brian - Host
But you go back to the statistics again, 81 percent of Asian students have two parents in the home. |
| 00:35:161 sec. |
Thernstrom, Abigail - Commissioner
It matters. |
| 00:35:174 sec. |
Lamb, Brian - Host
And 77 percent of black kids have only one parent in the home. |
| 00:35:2116 sec. |
Thernstrom, Abigail - Commissioner
That matters. But it unfortunately -- I mean, there is very good statistical work on this. It explains about a third of the gap -- well, all the demographic... |
| 00:35:372 sec. |
Lamb, Brian - Host
Go to TV. You write about television. |
| 00:35:391 sec. |
Thernstrom, Abigail - Commissioner
Yes. |
| 00:35:409 sec. |
Lamb, Brian - Host
Blacks watch on average -- kids, five hours of television a day, an hour more than white kids do. And a lot more than Asian kids do. How much does that... |
| 00:35:4932 sec. |
Thernstrom, Abigail - Commissioner
No, actually you have -- unless my memory doesn`t serve me correctly, the whites and Asians mysteriously don`t look that much different, and the black... |
| 00:36:217 sec. |
Lamb, Brian - Host
Stop there for a second. Define that phrase. You used it several times, social homework. What is it? |
| 00:36:2816 sec. |
Thernstrom, Abigail - Commissioner
It`s what they need to do to be socially acceptable to their peers, to be part of the group. Every teenager, every kid wants to be accepted by his or... |
| 00:36:444 sec. |
Lamb, Brian - Host
How much does that have to do with the parent not being there saying turn that off? |
| 00:36:4833 sec. |
Thernstrom, Abigail - Commissioner
That has something to do with it, but it also has to do obviously with -- well, it does have something to do with it. But I was going to say it also... |
| 00:37:2115 sec. |
Thernstrom, Abigail - Commissioner
So either they`re exaggerating the amount of television in order to feel that they sound American, or they`re putting television in the background and... |
| 00:37:3629 sec. |
Thernstrom, Abigail - Commissioner
But look, the extraordinary thing about Asians is not simply that their parents deliver the message, but that they listen to their parents. And we have... |
| 00:38:057 sec. |
Thernstrom, Abigail - Commissioner
And we also have -- you mentioned the Key academy, which is a KIPP Academy... |
| 00:38:121 sec. |
Lamb, Brian - Host
Here in Washington. |
| 00:38:1332 sec. |
Thernstrom, Abigail - Commissioner
Here in Washington, D.C., where the director of the Key has to say to a mother, you are not your child`s friend. Your child needs a mother. So it`s... |
| 00:38:4527 sec. |
Thernstrom, Abigail - Commissioner
I think inner city blacks are much more depressed about -- and that`s important, about what the possibilities are for them and their kids, and it is... |
| 00:39:1242 sec. |
Lamb, Brian - Host
Let me ask you this, then, because you have got 2001 statistics on the freshmen class in the following colleges and the percentage of the freshman class... |
| 00:39:541 min. |
Thernstrom, Abigail - Commissioner
Yes, and there are murmurings of that sort, and you left out the California system, Asians are 4 percent of the American population, they`re 10 percent... |
| 00:41:149 sec. |
Lamb, Brian - Host
On the back of your book, I want to mention who you have endorsing. This is praise for "American Black and White," which is another book. |
| 00:41:232 sec. |
Thernstrom, Abigail - Commissioner
Right. I was just going to say, don`t mix that up. |
| 00:41:2514 sec. |
Lamb, Brian - Host
No, I`m not. But I was interested in this. Linda Chavez, Tom Sowell, Shelby Steele, Alan Wolfe, James P. Wilson. And Henry Louis Gates. How did you... |
| 00:41:3938 sec. |
Thernstrom, Abigail - Commissioner
He read it, and he said, by God, you`ve got a good book here. And, you know, we`re extremely grateful to him. He`s intellectually willing to read books,... |
| 00:42:1719 sec. |
Lamb, Brian - Host
How often does it happen because you`re the authors, you and your husband Stephan are the authors of a book like this, that a lot of people in education,... |
| 00:42:361 min. |
Thernstrom, Abigail - Commissioner
It`s happened less with this book than with "American Black and White," and I can`t quite figure out why. And indeed our agents say, more controversy,... |
| 00:43:464 sec. |
Lamb, Brian - Host
The title of your book is "No Excuses." Where does that come from? |
| 00:43:5060 sec. |
Thernstrom, Abigail - Commissioner
Well, the schools we describe are often called no-excuses schools. And that predated the title of this book. But we have a larger meaning to it. We... |
| 00:44:5051 sec. |
Thernstrom, Abigail - Commissioner
So no excuses to the school, no excuses to the teachers. It`s responsibility all around here. No excuses to the kids, no excuses to the parents who... |
| 00:45:414 sec. |
Lamb, Brian - Host
How long have you and Stephan Thernstrom been married? |
| 00:45:454 sec. |
Thernstrom, Abigail - Commissioner
It will be 45 years in -- this January 3. |
| 00:45:491 sec. |
Lamb, Brian - Host
Where did you meet? |
| 00:45:501 sec. |
Thernstrom, Abigail - Commissioner
At Harvard graduate school. |
| 00:45:512 sec. |
Lamb, Brian - Host
Studying what? |
| 00:45:5328 sec. |
Thernstrom, Abigail - Commissioner
He was studying American history. Actually, in the program on degrees in American civilization, and at the time I was studying, if you can believe it,... |
| 00:46:211 sec. |
Lamb, Brian - Host
Where? |
| 00:46:2243 sec. |
Thernstrom, Abigail - Commissioner
Croton-on-Hudson, New York, which was known at the time for a lot of members of the American Communist Party and fellow travelers. And it was a very... |
| 00:47:053 sec. |
Lamb, Brian - Host
Where is he from? Meaning your husband, Stephan? |
| 00:47:0819 sec. |
Thernstrom, Abigail - Commissioner
He is from Battle Creek, Michigan, and before that, Port Huron, Michigan. Very, very different family than mine. My family in my teens moved to New... |
| 00:47:271 sec. |
Lamb, Brian - Host
Have you had children? |
| 00:47:281 sec. |
Thernstrom, Abigail - Commissioner
Two children, yes. |
| 00:47:291 sec. |
Lamb, Brian - Host
How old are they today? |
| 00:47:302 sec. |
Thernstrom, Abigail - Commissioner
36 and 39. |
| 00:47:322 sec. |
Lamb, Brian - Host
What kind of schools did they go to? |
| 00:47:3412 sec. |
Thernstrom, Abigail - Commissioner
They went to public schools in Lexington. Well, public schools in Los Angeles and then Lexington. Steve was teaching at UCLA for a while. And then they... |
| 00:47:461 sec. |
Lamb, Brian - Host
Have you ever taught? |
| 00:47:473 sec. |
Thernstrom, Abigail - Commissioner
Yes, at Harvard, I have. |
| 00:47:501 sec. |
Lamb, Brian - Host
For how long? |
| 00:47:5139 sec. |
Thernstrom, Abigail - Commissioner
Let me see, I had a lectureship for three years and then we went to England for a year. I gave it up. And then I came back on a visiting basis to teach... |
| 00:48:3032 sec. |
Lamb, Brian - Host
Take this book and what you`ve learned in all your studies and put yourself in the District of Columbia, where I think they spend as much as $15,000... |
| 00:49:0212 sec. |
Thernstrom, Abigail - Commissioner
Well, of course, D.C. has a potential voucher program on the table, and I would really push. |
| 00:49:145 sec. |
Lamb, Brian - Host
Let`s say no vouchers yet and you want to do something right now? |
| 00:49:1938 sec. |
Thernstrom, Abigail - Commissioner
Well, you`ve got to support your kid and you`ve got to scream bloody murder in the local school if you don`t think your kid is being properly taken... |
| 00:49:5724 sec. |
Thernstrom, Abigail - Commissioner
Any child that`s not reading by third grade, bells of alarm should go off in a parent`s head as well as teachers, instead of oh, well, he or she will... |
| 00:50:2113 sec. |
Lamb, Brian - Host
Yeah, but say again, you don`t really know what it is that should be expected of a child. I mean, how -- you are implying here that if you haven`t learned... |
| 00:50:3418 sec. |
Thernstrom, Abigail - Commissioner
Yeah. Though I would say there is -- I mean, KIPP schools, remember, are middle schools, and there are some high schools that are turning kids` lives... |
| 00:50:5237 sec. |
Thernstrom, Abigail - Commissioner
Look, you do the best you can to deliver the message to your kid that this is a country with its arms wide open for young people with skills and talent.... |
| 00:51:2917 sec. |
Lamb, Brian - Host
What if you`re not a reader? What if you just have an instinct, I want my kid to be the best and have the best education, and you`re just -- you know,... |
| 00:51:4640 sec. |
Thernstrom, Abigail - Commissioner
Well, in many cities -- I don`t actually know the D.C. scene, but there are a lot of privately funded scholarships that do get children out of the regular... |
| 00:52:2615 sec. |
Lamb, Brian - Host
What would you do with your child when it comes to the social homework that`s so important? I mean, you go so far in here as to talk about not allowing... |
| 00:52:4123 sec. |
Thernstrom, Abigail - Commissioner
The school has to not allow it. The parents can`t assume that burden all alone. Look, you asked where did we meet, do we have children and all that,... |
| 00:53:0437 sec. |
Thernstrom, Abigail - Commissioner
My kids watched very little television, because they had these terrible parents. They were allowed to watch on Saturday mornings, but by the time they... |
| 00:53:4117 sec. |
Thernstrom, Abigail - Commissioner
It`s hard to do that to your kids. And I`m not sure my kids would do that to their kids. So there are tradeoffs, but, you know, you`ve got to keep your... |
| 00:53:581 sec. |
Lamb, Brian - Host
Were your parents educated? |
| 00:53:591 sec. |
Thernstrom, Abigail - Commissioner
Yes, they were. |
| 00:54:002 sec. |
Lamb, Brian - Host
How many degrees? |
| 00:54:0217 sec. |
Thernstrom, Abigail - Commissioner
Well, my father, just short of a college degree, and my mother -- and the reason I`m hesitating is my mother died when I was fairly young. I think that... |
| 00:54:192 sec. |
Lamb, Brian - Host
Were there books in your both of your families? |
| 00:54:2127 sec. |
Thernstrom, Abigail - Commissioner
Books in my family, yes. In his family, yes, to some extent, even though his mother was only a high school graduate and, again, his father only eighth... |
| 00:54:4851 sec. |
Thernstrom, Abigail - Commissioner
Steve was thrilled when we wrote an article for "Reader`s Digest," because it had been his father`s education. And -- but Steve was a total delinquent... |
| 00:55:393 sec. |
Lamb, Brian - Host
So you -- both of you have got Harvard degrees? |
| 00:55:422 sec. |
Thernstrom, Abigail - Commissioner
I`m not undergraduate. |
| 00:55:441 sec. |
Lamb, Brian - Host
But Ph.D.`s? |
| 00:55:451 sec. |
Thernstrom, Abigail - Commissioner
Ph.D.`s, yes. |
| 00:55:462 sec. |
Lamb, Brian - Host
And both of your kids have Harvard degrees? |
| 00:55:481 sec. |
Thernstrom, Abigail - Commissioner
Yes. |
| 00:55:497 sec. |
Lamb, Brian - Host
You can imagine people saying, how could she possibly know the problems of an inner city school. |
| 00:55:5630 sec. |
Thernstrom, Abigail - Commissioner
I don`t know all the problems of an inner city school, but I am an American. I`m part of the society. I`ve had a -- I`ve been writing on issues of race... |
| 00:56:267 sec. |
Lamb, Brian - Host
Why is the right wing upset about this book and think that it`s an I.Q. problem? |
| 00:56:3348 sec. |
Thernstrom, Abigail - Commissioner
Well, I just said some. The flak we`ve gotten, interestingly enough, has been less from the left than -- well, there is -- look, there are a lot of... |
| 00:57:214 sec. |
Lamb, Brian - Host
I.Q., intelligence coefficient or intelligence quotient... |
| 00:57:251 sec. |
Thernstrom, Abigail - Commissioner
Quotient. |
| 00:57:262 sec. |
Lamb, Brian - Host
Quotient. And do you know what yours is? |
| 00:57:283 sec. |
Thernstrom, Abigail - Commissioner
No. And I don`t know what his is either. |
| 00:57:315 sec. |
Lamb, Brian - Host
But do people know -- I mean, how do we know? Who knows what someone`s I.Q. is? |
| 00:57:368 sec. |
Thernstrom, Abigail - Commissioner
I don`t know, but there`s a certain amount of -- a certain amount of I.Q. testing and social affairs, you know... |
| 00:57:442 sec. |
Lamb, Brian - Host
Do they still do it in schools? |
| 00:57:4620 sec. |
Thernstrom, Abigail - Commissioner
... there`s literature. That`s a very good question that I don`t know the answer to. I`ve asked it with the schools that we`ve looked at, have looked... |
| 00:58:066 sec. |
Lamb, Brian - Host
I have got to ask this, just as we get near the end, are you glad that you went on the Civil Rights Commission? |
| 00:58:1230 sec. |
Thernstrom, Abigail - Commissioner
Yes, I am. I am glad because I -- because race remains, as I said at the very beginning of this interview, it remains the American dilemma. You know,... |
| 00:58:429 sec. |
Lamb, Brian - Host
How much of what we see on our C-SPAN television screens when we cover the commissions between you and Mary Frances Berry is personal and how much of... |
| 00:58:514 sec. |
Thernstrom, Abigail - Commissioner
The personal is the political for her. |
| 00:58:552 sec. |
Lamb, Brian - Host
What does that mean? |
| 00:58:5719 sec. |
Thernstrom, Abigail - Commissioner
She can`t separate the two. She can`t separate the two. I really believe that I can totally. I have all sorts of friends whom I really disagree with... |
| 00:59:1613 sec. |
Lamb, Brian - Host
This is the cover of the book. Our guest has been the co-author, Abigail Thernstrom, with her husband, Stephan Thernstrom, and the title of this book... |
| 00:59:2949 sec. |
Thernstrom, Abigail - Commissioner
Thank you for having me, Brian. |