Tariq Ali takes a critical look at Barack Obama's presidency. He argues that President Obama has continued, without much change, George W. Bush's war on terrorism and has repeatedly capitulated to Republicans on domestic policy issues. Harper's magazine publisher John MacArthur and City University of New York professor Frances Fox Piven provided their own commentaries. Then the panelists responded to questions from members of the audience during this Brecht Forum co-sponsored by Verso Books.