John Brown's Trial

Oct 15, 2009

West Virginia Humanities Council

Brian McGinty talked about his book John Brown's Trial (Harvard University Press; October 15, 2009). In his book he recounts the trial of abolitionist John Brown who led an attack on the U.S. armory and arsenal in Harpers Ferry, West Virginia, on October 16, 1859. John Brown, who led twenty-one men in the attack, intended to foment a slave .. Read More
Brian McGinty talked about his book John Brown's Trial (Harvard University Press; October 15, 2009). In his book he recounts the trial of abolitionist John Brown who led an attack on the U.S. armory and arsenal in Harpers Ferry, West Virginia, on October 16, 1859. John Brown, who led twenty-one men in the attack, intended to foment a slave rebellion in Virginia. Following his capture Brown went to trial and was hanged in Charles Town, Virgina, on December 2, 1859. Mr. McGinty discussed the John Brown trial from the court house where it took place in what is now Charles Town, West Virgina. He characterized it as the most important trial in American history and listed a number of ways in which it was groundbreaking. He also raised questions about the fairness of the trial. Mr. McGinty responded to questions from members of the audience. This event in the Jefferson County Courthouse on Thursday, October 15, 2009, was sponsored by the West Virginia Humanities Council. Judge David Sanders gave a history of the courthouse and introduced the speaker. Brian McGinty, an attorney, is the author other books including Lincoln and the Court.

1 hours, 21 minutes | 959 Views

SHARE

  • SEND VIDEO
  • POST VIDEO TO FACEBOOK
  • BOOKMARK VIDEO

TRANSCRIPT

TIME SPEAKER TEXT
00:00:45 Unidentified Speaker GOOD EVENING EVERYONE END WILL COME TO THE COURTHOUSE AND JEFFERSON COUNTY. BEFORE I BEGAN AND THE...
00:09:32 Unidentified Speaker THANK YOU, KEN SULLIVAN AND SANDERS FOR THAT WONDERFUL INTRODUCTION. JUDGE SANDERS FELT THAT I ADDED...
00:50:45 Unidentified Speaker IN REGARDS TO JOHN BROWN'S SUPPOSE IT TREASON AGAINST THE STATE OF VIRGINIA ON THE GROUNDS THAT BECAUSE...
00:51:26 Unidentified Speaker OKAY, THAT'S -- THERE ARE WHOLE LIBRARIES ON THAT SUBJECT AND SOME OF THEM ARE VERY GOOD. JUDGE PARKER...
00:52:30 Unidentified Speaker LARRY LAWRENCE FROM THE JOHN BROWN SOCIETY. THANK YOU FOR YOUR EFFORTS. I HAVE COME TO THE CONCLUSION...
00:53:42 Unidentified Speaker THANK YOU APPRECIATE THOSE REMARKS. THEY ARE NOT REALLY GERMANE TO THE TRIAL SO I THINK WE WILL CONSIDER...
00:53:49 Unidentified Speaker AS I LISTEN TO YOU TALK ABOUT THE TRIAL, I AM THINKING OF THE TRIAL OF THE GERMAN RESISTANCE TO THE...
00:54:27 Unidentified Speaker WELCOME THAT'S AN ARGUMENT. YOU'VE MADE A GOOD ARGUMENT THERE. AND CERTAINLY THERE IS A GOOD BODY...
00:55:10 Unidentified Speaker CAN YOU TELL US WHAT HAPPENED TO THE OTHER DEFENDANTS?
00:55:13 Unidentified Speaker THEY WERE ALL HANG IT. THEY WERE ALL HANG IT. THERE WAS AT ONE TIME THERE WAS A EFFORT MADE TO TRY...
00:56:42 Unidentified Speaker WERE THEY ALL HANG HERE?
00:56:44 Unidentified Speaker YES THEY WERE BASED ALL OF THE HARPERS FERRY RAID. THEY WERE NEARLY IDENTICAL CHARGES. THERE WERE...
00:58:14 Unidentified Speaker [INAUDIBLE] -- HOW WAS TREASON DEFINED?
00:58:21 Unidentified Speaker WELL, TREASON AS DEFINED IN THE UNITED STATES CONSTITUTION AND A VERY SPECIFIC WAY. IT IS THE ONLY...
00:59:32 Unidentified Speaker A FEDERAL JUDGE WITH JURISDICTION OVER THIS AREA HAD [INAUDIBLE] -- WERE LAWS IN PLACE FOR THE FEDERAL...
00:59:45 Unidentified Speaker NO. THERE IS NO PROVISION IN THE CONSTITUTIONAL SYSTEM FOR THE FEDERAL GOVERNMENT TO INTERFERE WITH...
01:00:26 Unidentified Speaker I AM CURIOUS WHAT THE ATMOSPHERE WAS LIKE IN THE COURTROOM. WAS SECURITY VERY TIGHT? WERE THERE A...
01:00:39 Unidentified Speaker OKAY. THAT IS A GREAT QUESTION. THE STREETS WERE CROWDED WITH MILITIAMEN. JUDGE GOVERNOR WISE HAD...
01:02:27 Unidentified Speaker WHAT EXTENT DID WEISS STRUGGLE WITH THE DECISION TO EXECUTE BROWN? I KNOW HE WAS -- PEOPLE SENT LETTERS...
01:02:42 Unidentified Speaker JUDGE WEISS WAS GENERALLY BEING CHARACTERIZED AS MERCURIAL THE CHANGEABLE MAN WHO CHANGED HIS MIND...
01:06:34 Unidentified Speaker THERE WAS ANOTHER ATTORNEY DID RICHMOND I BELIEVE HIS NAME WAS WILLIAM GREEN WHO WAS A BROTHER OF...
01:08:01 Unidentified Speaker [INAUDIBLE] THE INDIVIDUALS TURNING AGAINST THE STATE OF VIRGINIA?
01:08:22 Unidentified Speaker I BELIEVE THERE WAS A TRIAL THAT INVOLVE THE PRIEST AGAINST VIRGINIA. THAT WAS ANOTHER ONE. WEST...
01:09:42 Unidentified Speaker DAY SAINT JOHN BROWN CONFESSION OR UNDERSTANDING IS A CHANGE THAT WENT ON THE?
01:09:47 Unidentified Speaker YES. I DO THINK THERE WAS A CHANGE IN THE GROUND. IN THE BEGINNING I THINK HE THOUGHT HE MIGHT ACTUALLY...
01:10:52 Unidentified Speaker IT WAS NOT A CRIME. IT WAS PART OF PERHAPS AIDING AND ABETTING THE MURDER BECAUSE THERE WERE FOUR...
01:12:18 Unidentified Speaker [INAUDIBLE]
01:12:26 Unidentified Speaker WOULD YOU REPEAT THAT PLEASE?
01:12:29 Unidentified Speaker COULD THAT HAVE BEEN THE REASON THAT THAT TARGET WAS INCLUDED?
01:12:34 Unidentified Speaker FABS MIGHT HAVE BEEN. I THINK HOWEVER THAT A LOT OF THE MISTAKES THAT WERE MADE DURING THE TRIAL CAN...
01:13:29 Unidentified Speaker WHEN BROWN SURRENDERED HE WAS HANGED CUSTODY HOW DID THEY LOSE CONTROL AND DID THE CONSTITUTION PLAY...
01:13:48 Unidentified Speaker I DID NOT GET THE FIRST
01:13:51 Unidentified Speaker [INAUDIBLE] UNITED STATES ARMY.
01:13:57 Unidentified Speaker YES THEY TURNED HIM OVER TO STATE AUTHORITIES QUITE QUICKLY AND THIS WAS ANOTHER MISTAKE IF THEY HAD...
01:15:28 Unidentified Speaker IF THEY BROUGHT INTO EVIDENCE WOULD HE STILL HAVE
01:15:33 Unidentified Speaker YES. I THINK HE WOULD HAVE BEEN. HOW THAT SATISFIES YOU? [LAUGHTER] HE BROKE A LOT. IN A VIOLENT...
01:17:00 Unidentified Speaker THE DEAL LOOKED AT THE MURDER. [INAUDIBLE]
01:17:04 Unidentified Speaker YES. REFERRING TO THE EARLIER TRIAL THAT HAD ARISEN OUT OF HARPER'S FERRY? THERE WAS A GOOD POINT...
01:18:06 Unidentified Speaker I THE QUESTION OF YOUR RITE AID PROCESS SINCE YOU MENTIONED THERE IS NO TRANSCRIPT OF THE TRIAL.
01:18:15 Unidentified Speaker NO OFFICIAL TRANSCRIPT.
01:18:22 Unidentified Speaker YOU DID RESEARCH AND LOOKING AT THE SENSATIONAL RISK PENDING THE TRIAL DO HAVE ANY TROUBLE STRUGGLING...
01:18:44 Unidentified Speaker IN PARTICULAR THERE WERE SEVERAL NEW YORK NEWSPAPERS ARE REPRESENTED DURING THEIR TRIAL AND ONE GARNERED...
01:20:11 Unidentified Speaker [APPLAUSE]
01:20:36 Unidentified Speaker SHALL WE GO TO THE SIGNING TABLE?
01:20:42 Unidentified Speaker THANK YOU. HE WILL BE DELIGHTED TO SIGN YOUR BOOK YOU CARE TO PURCHASE ONE THE HISTORICAL SOCIETY...

NOTE: The transcript for this program was compiled from uncorrected Closed Captioning.

RELATED PROGRAMS

PEOPLE GRID LIST

  • McGinty, Brian
  • Sanders, David H.

PURCHASE