Sotomayor Confirmation Hearing, Day 4, Legal Issues Panel

Jul 16, 2009

Senate Committee Judiciary

The Senate Judiciary Committee held its fourth day of hearings on the appointment of Judge Sonia Sotomayor to the U.S. Supreme Court seat vacated by the retirement of Justice David Souter. Witnesses called by both the majority and minority members testified about their impressions of Judge Sotomayor, her record, and their views of her .. Read More
The Senate Judiciary Committee held its fourth day of hearings on the appointment of Judge Sonia Sotomayor to the U.S. Supreme Court seat vacated by the retirement of Justice David Souter. Witnesses called by both the majority and minority members testified about their impressions of Judge Sotomayor, her record, and their views of her qualifications for a place on the Supreme Court. Among the topics they addressed were her approach to various cases, Second Amendment and gun ownership issues, abortion, and property rights. Mr. Cone also testified about her in settling the baseball players strike of 1994. Further panels testified about the nomination on subsequent parts.

1 hours, 9 minutes | 1,046 Views

View Entire Event (9 Programs)

SHARE

  • SEND VIDEO
  • POST VIDEO TO FACEBOOK
  • BOOKMARK VIDEO

EMBED THIS VIDEO

Copy the code below and paste it into your website:

MORE OPTIONS

Change Size

TRANSCRIPT

TIME SPEAKER TEXT
00:00:56 Klobuchar, AmyU.S. Senator

Okay, I think we're going to start

our third panel here, if everyone could be seated.

I...

00:01:31 Klobuchar, AmyU.S. Senator

Thank you. We're going to start. I'll

introduce each of you, and then you'll give your five...

00:02:38 Freeh, Louis J.Senior Vice Chair & Gen. Couns

Thank you very much. Senator, good afternoon.

Senator Sessions, good afternoon to you.

It's...

00:08:09 Klobuchar, AmyU.S. Senator

Thank you very much. Thank you for your

testimony.

Next we have Chuck Canterbury. Chuck...

00:08:49 Canterbury, ChuckNational President

Thank you, Madame Chair. Ranking Member

Sessions, Senator Hatch, it's a pleasure to be here...

00:13:23 Klobuchar, AmyU.S. Senator

Thank you very much, Mr. Canterbury.

Next is David Cone. David Cone is a former Major League...

00:13:57 Cone, DavidPitcher

Thank you, Senator Klobuchar. Senator Sessions,

Senator Hatch, nice to see you again.

On...

00:19:06 Klobuchar, AmyU.S. Senator

Thank you very much, Mr. Cone.

Our next witness is Kate Stith. She is the Lafayette S. Foster

professor...

00:19:45 Stith, KateProfessor

I thank you, Senators, for the opportunity to comment

on the nomination of Judge Sonia Sotomayor,...

00:25:30 Klobuchar, AmyU.S. Senator

Thank you very much.

We next have Dr. Charmaine Yoest, who is the president and CEO of

Americans...

00:26:07 Yoest, Charmaine

Thank you very much, Senator Klobuchar, Ranking

Member Sessions and members of the committee,...

00:32:59 Klobuchar, AmyU.S. Senator

Thank you very much.

Next we have Sandy Froman. Sandy Froman is the past president of

the...

00:32:59 Froman, Sandra S.President

Thank you, Madame Chair.

Chairman Leahy, Ranking Member Sessions, Senator Hatch, thank you

for...

00:32:59 Klobuchar, AmyU.S. Senator

Thank you very much for your testimony, Ms.

Froman.

Our next witness is David Kopel. He...

00:32:59 Kopel, David B.Research Director

Thank you. The case of Sonia Sotomayor versus the

Second Amendment is not yet found in the record...

00:32:59 Klobuchar, AmyU.S. Senator

Thank you very much. And did I say your name

correctly? Oh, well, that was good. Thank you.

Next,...

00:44:58 Somin, IlyaAssistant Professor

Thank you very much. I'd like to thank the committee

for the opportunity to testify, and even...

00:50:18 Klobuchar, AmyU.S. Senator

Thank you very much for your testimony.

We are now going to have each senator ask five minutes...

00:50:40 Freeh, Louis J.Senior Vice Chair & Gen. Couns

You know, I think all the qualities that we've heard

in this hearing as the optimal qualities:...

00:52:01 Klobuchar, AmyU.S. Senator

As someone who was appointed by George H. -- by

President H.W.

Bush, do you have any reservations...

00:52:16 Freeh, Louis J.Senior Vice Chair & Gen. Couns

No, I'm totally confident that this would be an

outstanding judge. And whether it was President...

00:52:46 Klobuchar, AmyU.S. Senator

Thank you.

Mr. Canterbury, you spent more than 25 years as an active-duty

police officer...

00:53:13 Canterbury, ChuckNational President

We're very confident of that. Based on the over

450 criminal cases that we reviewed, we felt...

00:53:31 Klobuchar, AmyU.S. Senator

Thank you very much.

Just as I said Mr. Freeh was the only one on the panel that

served...

00:54:20 Cone, DavidPitcher

Well, thank you, Senator.

You know, from my perspective, as I said in my statement, a lot

of...

00:55:16 Klobuchar, AmyU.S. Senator

Thank you very much.

Senator Sessions.

00:55:19 Sessions, JeffU.S. Senator

Thank you, Madame Chairman. It's

good to be with you, and we're glad you're on this committee.

00:55:23 Klobuchar, AmyU.S. Senator

Thank you.

00:55:26 Sessions, JeffU.S. Senator

Mr. Cone, I was reading a story about statistical

stuff the other day. And it came to me that,...

00:55:56 Cone, DavidPitcher

It makes you wonder, yes.

00:55:57 Sessions, JeffU.S. Senator

Two or three is about all (they're worth ?),

right?

No, it is -- thank you for your testimony....

00:56:42 Freeh, Louis J.Senior Vice Chair & Gen. Couns

I think that's correct. But I also think he's

supporting this nomination now.

00:56:45 Sessions, JeffU.S. Senator

Okay. That's a good comment. You did good.

Ms. Stith, thank you for your very insightful comments....

00:57:23 Yoest, Charmaine

(Off mike.)

00:57:25 Klobuchar, AmyU.S. Senator

You have to turn you --

00:57:27 Sessions, JeffU.S. Senator

Push your button.

00:57:27 Klobuchar, AmyU.S. Senator

Push the button.

00:57:30 Yoest, Charmaine

I was asked that question actually right after Judge

Sotomayor was nominated, and it was the...

00:58:24 Sessions, JeffU.S. Senator

Well, I think that's probably -- most boards

should operate that way, at least.

Ms. Froman,...

00:58:58 Froman, Sandra S.President

That's correct, Senator. The problem is, the Heller

case did not have to deal with the incorporation...

00:59:24 Sessions, JeffU.S. Senator

Did it worry you that the judge who's already

ruled on the case one way -- and it was a five-to-four...

00:59:36 Froman, Sandra S.President

It's -- it's of great concern to me, Senator. And

that's why I'm here today to testify. And...

01:00:07 Sessions, JeffU.S. Senator

Now, I know your organization officially -- I see

today they said they wanted to see how the...

01:00:25 Froman, Sandra S.President

Well, I have, of course, been here today. And I'm

not here to speak on behalf of the NRA. I'm...

01:00:49 Sessions, JeffU.S. Senator

Well, I -- are you aware that I was just given a

document here that said that -- "therefore,...

01:01:02 Froman, Sandra S.President

I was told about that while I was here, Senator,

yes.

01:01:04 Sessions, JeffU.S. Senator

Okay.

01:01:05 Froman, Sandra S.President

And so I'm sure that they have given a full

explanation of that position, and I'm glad to see...

01:01:12 Sessions, JeffU.S. Senator

Mr. Somin, thank you for your testimony.

Thank you, Mr. Kopel, for yours.

And I'm going...

01:01:49 Klobuchar, AmyU.S. Senator

Time -- (off mike).

01:01:50 Somin, IlyaAssistant Professor

Yes, thank you, Senator. I agree with you it raises

very important concerns. And these sorts...

01:02:14 Sessions, JeffU.S. Senator

Thank you.

01:02:16 Klobuchar, AmyU.S. Senator

Thank you very much.

Senator Kyl.

01:02:19 Kyl, JonU.S. Senator

Thank you. Madame Chairman, first of all,

let me acknowledge those on the panel who I know....

01:02:41 Sessions, JeffU.S. Senator

Did you -- are -- Senator Bunning's -- did you --

the -- was his perfect game the last one when...

01:02:49 Cone, DavidPitcher

No, his was done back in the '60s. But there's only,

I think, 17 perfect games in the history...

01:02:57 Kyl, JonU.S. Senator

Yeah.

And, of course, Dr. Yoest.

And Sandy Froman is a person with whom I have consulted...

01:04:19 Froman, Sandra S.President

Yes. Thank you, Senator Kyl. Well, I believe, I

heard you questioning one of the panels earlier,...

01:05:46 Kyl, JonU.S. Senator

Thank you very much.

Dr. Yoest, in the questioning by Senator Coburn of the nominee,

he...

01:06:31 Yoest, Charmaine

Well, I would reference back to the confirmation

hearings of the chief justice, in which he...

01:07:36 Kyl, JonU.S. Senator

Thank you.

Just to be clear, I had recalled her testimony slightly

incorrectly. She actually...

01:07:58 Yoest, Charmaine

Yes, sir.

01:07:58 Kyl, JonU.S. Senator

Okay. Thank you. Again, I wish I had more time to --

but we have, I think, one or two panels...

01:08:06 Klobuchar, AmyU.S. Senator

Senator, we have two panels left.

01:08:08 Kyl, JonU.S. Senator

Yes. But we thank you very much. This is an

important event in our country's history. You've...

01:08:17 Sessions, JeffU.S. Senator

And thank you, Mr. Canterbury. I appreciate the

FOPs.

01:08:20 Klobuchar, AmyU.S. Senator

Yeah. I wanted to thank all of you. And you

did a marvelous job in stating your opinions. I...

RELATED PROGRAMS

PEOPLE GRID LIST

  • Canterbury, Chuck
  • Cone, David
  • Freeh, Louis J.
  • Froman, Sandra S.
  • Kopel, David B.
  • Somin, Ilya
  • Stith, Kate
  • Yoest, Charmaine
  • Klobuchar, Amy
  • Kyl, Jon
  • Sessions, Jeff

PURCHASE