SHARE
TRANSCRIPT
| TIME | SPEAKER | TEXT |
|---|---|---|
| 00:54:53 |
|
IS THE LIGHT MOTIF OF THE OPINION. ONE CANNOT AVOID A STRONG SENSE OF DEJAVU ON READING THE ELABORATION... |
| 01:13:36 |
|
I CERTAINLY KNOW MORE ABOUT FOOTNOTES THAN I EVER CARED TO KNOW. I WILL SAY, HOWEVER, ONE PIECE OF... |
| 01:14:42 |
|
LET'S OPEN THIS UP FOR QUESTIONS OR REACTIONS. I KNOW YOU'VE BEEN DISRIB LING THEM DOWN DURING THESE... |
| 01:15:01 |
|
I WANT TO THANK THE LAW REVIEW FOR ORGANIZEING THIS WELL DONE, VERY SUBSTANTIVE, AND ESPECIALLY TO... |
| 01:15:56 |
|
I WOULD LIKE TO SPEAK FIRST. I DON'T THINK JUSTICE GINSBURG HAS WRITTEN IN ANY OF THE DETAINEE CASES.... |
| 01:17:59 |
|
GOOD WAY TO START. DO WE HAVE ANOTHER QUESTION HERE? PLEASE. |
| 01:18:04 |
|
I GUESS THIS IS DIRECTED TOWARD PROFESSOR BAXTER. I HAD BEEN FOLLOWING PRETTY CLOSELY THE MINNESOTA... |
| 01:18:54 |
|
I THINK THE LATTER IS LIKELY. THERE IS ALSO LITIGATION THAT'S FARTHER ALONG. WE SHOULD KNOW MORE ABOUT... |
| 01:20:08 |
|
I'LL A LITTLE BIAS MY OPINION OF THE CASE, BUT YEAH, I MEAN, THEIR ARGUMENT IS THAT THE STANDARDS... |
| 01:20:43 |
|
I ONLY FOLLOWED BY 538.COM WHICH SHALL OF YOU WAY LOOKED AT DURING THE ELECTION TO SEE WHETHER OR... |
| 01:21:05 |
|
PROBABLY NOT, BUT THEY'RE GOING TO KEEP APPEALING IT, AND I WAS THINKING -- IT'S PROBABLY GOING TO... |
| 01:21:11 |
|
THAT'S RIGHT. |
| 01:21:12 |
|
IT MIGHT GO EVEN HIGHER. |
| 01:21:13 |
|
THAT'S RIGHT. MY ONLY COMMENT IS THAT IT SOUNDS LIKE THE CASE TURNS ON THE QUESTION OF MINNESOTA ... |
| 01:21:26 |
|
WE'RE PREPARED TO SERVE WHEREVER NECESSARY. WE'RE A GREAT BELIEVER IN STATE CONSTITUTIONS, OF ALL ... |
| 01:21:39 |
|
GOOD AFTERNOON, THANK YOU FOR COMING, AT THE EXPENSE OF EMBARRASSING MYSELF FOR COMING IN LATE, I... |
| 01:22:33 |
|
YEAH, I THINK IT WAS SOMEWHERE IN THE MIDDLE. JUSTICE KENNEDY, RIGHT, IS THE ONE WHO USES NO FOOTNOTES... |
| 01:23:30 |
|
SHE'S GOING TO SAY, JAY, I THINK THERE'S A TENTH CATEGORY THAT MAYBE JUSTICE GINSBURG DOESN'T USE,... |
| 01:24:15 |
|
AND JUSTICE WHITE, THE KERMUJJEN AND PROFESSIONAL ATHLETE THAT HE WAS REFUSED TO JOIN THAT PART OF... |
| 01:24:30 |
|
WAS IT THE PARTICULAR -- |
| 01:24:33 |
|
JUSTICE BLACKMON IT TURNED OUT DIDN'T LIKE HIS OWN FOOTNOTE BECAUSE HE LAMENTED HE HAD LEFT OUT MEL... |
| 01:24:42 |
|
THAT'S THE DANGER OF MAKING LONG LISTS. |
| 01:24:44 |
|
COMING UP WITH NAMES OF PEOPLE THAT HAVE BEEN OMITTED, I CAN'T REMEMBER WHO THEY WERE, RALPH KEINER... |
| 01:24:58 |
|
SHE WOULD NEVER DO THAT AND NEVER HAVE A FOOTNOTE LIKE JUSTICE SUDER'S FOOTNOTE THAT TELLS THE STORY... |
| 01:25:27 |
|
THANK YOU FOR COMING. I HAVE A QUESTION FOR EACH OF YOU. SINCE YOU ARE ALL CLERKS FOR JUSTICE GINSBURG,... |
| 01:25:48 |
|
I MENTIONED ONE THING JUST BRIEFLY IN THE TALK, IT WAS THE STRATEGY OF DISSENT WRITING. I HAD WORKED... |
| 01:27:18 |
|
BOY, SHE I THINK -- RESTRAINT WOULD BE THE WORD I WOULD USE. I MEAN, SHE'S REALLY -- I THINK PI HER... |
| 01:28:26 |
|
THAT'S MUCH SAID THAN I COULD, AND I WOULD AGREE WITH THOSE SENTIMENTS, TOO. IT'S INTERESTING, IF YOU... |
| 01:29:07 |
|
OTHER QUESTIONS. PREEMPTION ISN'T BUBBLING UP TO THE TOP OF THE LIST? ACTUALLY I DO HAVE A PREEMPTION... |
| 01:29:27 |
|
RIGHT. SO THE QUESTION IS ABOUT WHETHER JUSTICE GINSBURG HAD THE LAST LAUGH BECAUSE AFTER THE MEDICAL... |
| 01:31:09 |
|
PLEASE, MORE QUESTIONS, ANYONE, BUT THERE WAS ACTUALLY ANOTHER PREEMPTION CASE DECIDED NOT TOO LONG... |
| 01:31:20 |
|
ALTRIA. |
| 01:31:22 |
|
ALTRIA, YEAH, AND I DON'T REMEMBER WHO WAS OBJECT WHAT SIDE OF THAT. DO YOU REMEMBER? |
| 01:31:26 |
|
-- ON THAT SIDE OF THAT. DO YOU REMEMBER? |
| 01:31:28 |
|
THERE WAS THE CIGARETTE CASE, RIGHT, SO A GROUP OF SMOKERS SUED PHILIP MORRIS, WHICH HAS BEEN REBRANDED... |
| 01:32:55 |
|
MORE QUESTIONS? GOOD, ANOTHER QUESTION. OTHERWISE WE'RE GOING TO HAVE TO DRINK COFFEE. |
| 01:33:02 |
|
I GUESS I SHOULD BE MORE -- IF I'M MORE INTERESTED IN THE PERSON THAN THE ACTUAL JURISPRUDENCE, BUT... |
| 01:34:09 |
|
JUST BEFORE OUR SESSION GIANNOO NOT THE FORM AT SESSION, WE WERE JUST TALKING ABOUT. IT WAS MENTIONED... |
| 01:35:21 |
|
AND I DON'T THINK THERE'S ANYTHING INCONSISTENT WITH THINKING ABOUT YOUR JOB AS A SUPREME COURT JUSTICE... |
| 01:35:59 |
|
JUSTICE GINSBURG LOVES JUDGES AND SHE LOVES MEETING JUDGES, SHE TRAVELS AROUND THE WORLD TO SEMINARS... |
| 01:36:53 |
|
THANK YOU ALL FOR COMING. ONE QUESTION THAT GOES OFF OF WHAT YOU SAID, RECENTLY I BELIEVE JUSTICE... |
| 01:37:46 |
|
NOTHING COMES TO MIND. |
| 01:37:48 |
|
SURELY SHE UNDERSTANDS THAT THE INSTITUTION IS MOST RESPECTED, IS ONE THAT IS RESTRAINED AND MEASURED... |
| 01:38:23 |
|
I THINK THE STUDYIES CAN -- I CAN'T QUOTE THE NUMBERS BUT THE STUDIES HAVE SHOWN THAT JUSTICE GINSBURG,... |
| 01:39:48 |
|
YET THERE WAS ALSO BMI. |
| 01:39:49 |
|
THERE WAS ALSO BMI. |
| 01:39:50 |
|
I DON'T KNOW -- EXCEPT FOR BMI. NO, BUT BMI WAS -- I DON'T KNOW HOW YOU WOULD -- |
| 01:39:56 |
|
SO THERE'S A FOOTNOTE HANGING OVER THIS ENTIRE PANEL, RIGHT, OR AN END NOTE HANGING UNDER IT, WHICH... |
| 01:40:29 |
|
WE'LL BE SPENDING TIME LATER TODAY TALKING ABOUT THAT. ALL RIGHT. |
| 01:40:37 |
|
IT WAS ACTUALLY ABOUT THE LILLY LEDBETTER CASE SO IT MAY NOT BE RELEVANT NOW, BUT MY QUESTION WOULD... |
| 01:41:34 |
|
I HAVEN'T READ THE LED BETTER DISSENT RECENTLY BUT I DON'T THINK IT'S INTEMPORATE IN ITS TONE SO ... |
| 01:43:04 |
|
IN MY CASE, IT TURNED OUT TO BE 7-1, SHE WROTE THE MANAGEORITY OPINION AND GOT THE CHIEF JUSTICE TO... |
| 01:44:00 |
|
ALL RIGHT. SHOULD WE TAKE A BREAK? WHY DON'T WE TAKE A BREAK. I'M SORRY, THERE'S ANOTHER QUESTION.... |
| 01:44:10 |
|
GO AHEAD, SIR. |
| 01:44:12 |
|
I'LL TRY TO KEEP IT SHORT. ALLUDING TO SOMETHING YOU BROUGHT UP TWO ANSWERS AGO, PROFESSOR FRANKLIN,... |
| 01:44:46 |
|
SOMETHING IN THE BLOG SHEER, SOMETHING LIKE THAT, WHERE SOMEBODY WAS CRITICIZE ING HER FOR CREATING... |
| 01:45:20 |
|
IT WOULD BE AN INTERESTING STUDY TO SEE HOW MANY CALLS FOR HELP YOU CAN FIND AND SEE WHAT THE PERCENTAGE... |
| 01:45:47 |
|
I UNDERSTAND THE CRITICISM CORRECTLY, I THINK IT CENTERS ON AN IMPERCEIVED PROPRIETY FROM DOING THAT... |
| 01:46:26 |
|
I THRNG ARE STAFFERS IN THE HOUSE JUDICIARY COMMITTEES THAT READ OPINIONS AND DISSENTS IN ORDER TO... |
| 01:46:40 |
|
IT'S QUITE INTERESTING. IN ONE OF THE READINGS, I CAN'T REMEMBER WHICH OF THE PIECES I WAS LOOKING... |
| 01:48:09 |
|
WHEN ARE WE GOING TO RECONVENE. 3:00. |
| 01:48:13 |
|
NOTE: The transcript for this program was compiled from uncorrected Closed Captioning.
