American Civil-Military Relations

Apr 29, 2008

U.S. Army Command and General Staff College

A panel discussion was held on civilian-military relations from U.S. Army Command and General Staff College in Fort Leavenworth, Kansas. Panelists were Dale Herspring, author of Rumsfeld's Wars; Marybeth Ulrich, author of Democratizing Communist Militaries; Col. Matthew Moten, author of The Delafield Commission and the .. Read More
A panel discussion was held on civilian-military relations from U.S. Army Command and General Staff College in Fort Leavenworth, Kansas. Panelists were Dale Herspring, author of Rumsfeld's Wars; Marybeth Ulrich, author of Democratizing Communist Militaries; Col. Matthew Moten, author of The Delafield Commission and the American Military Profession; and Peter Feaver, author of Armed Servants. Don Snider, co-author of The Future of the Army Profession moderated.

1 hours, 49 minutes | 97 Views

SHARE

  • SEND VIDEO
  • POST VIDEO TO FACEBOOK
  • BOOKMARK VIDEO

TRANSCRIPT

TIME SPEAKER TEXT
00:00:03 Unidentified Speaker UP NEXT A PANEL DISCUSSION ON CIVILIAN-MILITARY RELATION IS. PANELESTS INCLUDE DALE HERS SPRING....
00:00:44 Unidentified Speaker GOOD AFTERNOON. MY NAME IS DR. TED THOMAS. I'M DIRECTOR FOR THE DEPARTMENT OF COMMAND AND LEADERSHIP....
00:04:12 Unidentified Speaker THANK YOU, TOM. DELIGHT TO BE HERE, FOLKS. I HOPE YOU ENJOYED THE PRESENTATION BY GENERAL POWELL...
00:16:49 Unidentified Speaker THANK YOU ALL FOR BEING HERE. IT'S AN HONOR FOR ME TO BE PART OF THIS PANEL AND HONOR TO BE HERE...
00:24:28 Unidentified Speaker THANK YOU. I WANT TO LOOK AT BIT DIFFERENTLY, A LOT OF YOU, CIVIL-MILITARY THING MAY COME AL AT YOU...
00:30:58 Unidentified Speaker GOOD. THANK YOU. MARY BETH.
00:31:01 Unidentified Speaker I WAS TOLD MILITARY THING, BETTER MAKE IT TEN MINUTES AND TEN MINUTES EXACTLY.
00:31:06 Unidentified Speaker MY ERROR. PETER, YOU'RE UP YOU'RE DOING IT TO ME AGAIN. YOU'RING ME OFF. I'VE BEEN ASKED TO COMMENT...
00:44:36 Unidentified Speaker THANK YOU, PETER. MARY-BETH.
00:44:39 Unidentified Speaker HI. GREAT PLEASURE TO BE HERE. MY FIRST TRIP TO FORT LEAVENWORTH. I HOPE IT'S NOT MY LAST. I HOPE...
00:58:22 Unidentified Speaker THANK YOU, MARYBETH. THERE YOU HAVE IT, FOLKS, NOW IT'S TIME FOR US TO LISTEN TO YOU. AND IF I COULD,...
00:58:49 Unidentified Speaker PANEL NUMBER TWO, FIRST.
00:58:51 Unidentified Speaker GOOD AFTERNOON. MAJOR MARY -- 15 ALPHA. ARE A COUPLE PANEL MEMBERS THAT COULD ANSWER IT. YOU MENTIONED...
00:59:19 Unidentified Speaker WHY DON'T WE START OUT WITH AN EASY QUESTION. THE WHOLE ARMY IS WRESTLING WITH THIS. FOR THOSE WHO...
01:06:50 Unidentified Speaker I'M GOING TO STOP THE PANEL. WE CAN ALL FIVE TALK ABOUT EVERY QUESTION BUT THAT WON'T HEAR FROM YOU...
01:07:00 Unidentified Speaker MAJOR FROM 17 DELTA. I WOULD LIKE TO ASK YOU TO CLARIFY PERHAPS ONE OF YOUR MORE PROVOKING COMMENTS....
01:09:12 Unidentified Speaker AND MY ANSWER IS, NO, YOU DID NOT HEAR ME RIGHT. ABSOLUTELY IT IS ESSENTIAL OF THE BACK TO THE SENIOR...
01:11:44 Unidentified Speaker LET ME FOLLOW UP ON THAT. AN EXAMPLE OF WHAT WOULD BE INAPPROPRIATE, WITH LEE WAS TOUCHING AT, I HAD...
01:13:30 Unidentified Speaker LET ME SUMMARIZE THIS BEFORE THE NEXT QUESTION BY POSING A QUESTION BACK TO YOU AND THIS COMES FROM...
01:15:19 Unidentified Speaker MAJOR TAYLOR, A SMALL GROUP BUILT UP AND CONTINUING ALONG THE MAIN OF MILITARY ADVICE AND SAID, SHOULD...
01:15:34 Unidentified Speaker A QUESTION. ONE OF THE THINGS I INTRODUCED IN THIS BOOK WAS A TALK ABOUT CIVIL MILITARY AND MILITIAS...
01:17:53 Unidentified Speaker I'D LIKE TO ADDRESS THIS IN A SLIGHTLY DIFFERENT WAY. IN YOUR QUESTION WAS, IS THERE A TIME HAVING...
01:20:44 Unidentified Speaker WAS CUT TO A QUESTION FOR AND THEN TWO.
01:20:46 Unidentified Speaker THE STAFF GROUP THREE ALPHA, I WOULD LIKE TO DIRECT THIS TO DR. PETER FEAVER BECAUSE I'M PROBABLY...
01:21:06 Unidentified Speaker THAT IS MY SPECIALTY.
01:21:09 Unidentified Speaker ARE DOING A GOOD JOB AT A.
01:21:10 Unidentified Speaker I AM TEMPTED TO SAY BY THE BOOK BUT I DON'T THINK THAT WOULD HELP ACTUALLY.
01:21:16 Unidentified Speaker I'M NOT AN ACADEMIC, I HAVEN'T WRITTEN ANY BOOKS, BUT I HAVE BEEN DOWNRANGE A COUPLE TIMES WITH A...
01:21:44 Unidentified Speaker WELL, I WAS AN ADVISER AND NOT A DECISION MAKER. SO I WORKED DIRECTLY FOR THE STEVE HADLEY WHO IS...
01:25:05 Unidentified Speaker PANEL TWO?
01:25:07 Unidentified Speaker MICHELE REED, 16 TILTON. COL. MOTEN, YOU MENTIONED IN YOUR INITIAL STATEMENTS THAT A POTENTIAL RESPONSE...
01:25:33 Unidentified Speaker I DID NOT HEAR THE BARRY LAST PART.
01:25:36 Unidentified Speaker SERGEY BELIEVE ANY MEDIA'S BEEN TO AN ARMY RESPONSE OF BAD BEHAVIOR WOULD BE MORE DAMAGING THAN THE...
01:25:46 Unidentified Speaker TO BE HONEST WITH YOU, I AM APPROACHING THIS FROM THE STANDPOINT OF WHAT IS GOOD FOR THE PROFESSION...
01:27:29 Unidentified Speaker PANEL THREE, OVER ON THIS SIDE AND.
01:27:33 Unidentified Speaker GENTLEMAN, AND LADY, 11 BROUGHT UP. I AM A DIFFERENT ANGLE ON SOLD MILITARY RELATIONS, KIND OF CONCERN...
01:28:27 Unidentified Speaker I WILL TAKE THE FIRST TAB. WHILE THE REST OF THE PANEL IS THINKING ABOUT IT. THERE IS TOO DANGEROUS...
01:31:58 Unidentified Speaker NOW,ING ON MY CLOTHE AS COLONEL MATT MOTEN, US ARMY, I AM NOT COMPETENT TO MAKE THAT JUDGMENT. THE...
01:32:41 Unidentified Speaker WE HAVE TIME FOR TWO MORE QUESTIONS, WE'LL GO FOUR AND THEN THREE, FOUR, PLEASE?
01:32:46 Unidentified Speaker YES, SIR. MAJOR RUSSO, 22 BRAVO. TO KIND OF SECOND WHAT MAJOR JASON SAID, I THINK I SPEAK FOR A LOT...
01:33:17 Unidentified Speaker LET ME SPEAK TO THIS. THIS WAS A MAJOR CONCERN ABOUT TEN YEARS AGO. TEN, 12 YEARS AGO. THERE WAS...
01:35:43 Unidentified Speaker AND I SUSPECT THAT YOU WILL DISCOVER THEY ARE VERY, VERY DIFFERENT IN MANY RESPECTS AND YET, THIS...
01:36:29 Unidentified Speaker FINAL WELL, PANEL 3.
01:36:31 Unidentified Speaker YES, SIR. MAJOR LAURIE, I'M A STILL ANGRY ABOUT TWO THINGS. ONE IS, SIR, COLONEL MOTEN YOU TALKED...
01:38:42 Unidentified Speaker DO IT BRIEFLY.
01:38:46 Unidentified Speaker OKAY, LEET ME TAKE A CRACK THAT AND IF OTHERS WANTED TO AS WELL, BUT THAT THIS IS HEART OF THE WHOLE,...
01:41:48 Unidentified Speaker LET ME ALSO ADDRESS, WE ARE -- WHEN I TALKED TO CIVILIANS, AUDIENCES, I MAKE SOME OF THE POINTS THAT...
01:43:42 Unidentified Speaker AND SINCE WE HAVE SOME PEOPLE THAT HAVE FLIGHTS I'M GOING TO EXERT THE MODERATOR'S PREROGATIVE AND...
01:45:18 Unidentified Speaker I WOULD LIKE TO, BEFORE YOU GET UP, SIR, AND MA'AM, I THINK IT IS CLEAR THAT WE HAVE MUCH TO STUDY....
01:48:38 Unidentified Speaker IT SAYS NOTHING IN THERE ABOUT ONLY THOSE PORTIONS OF THE CONSTITUTION THAT ARE CONVENIENT OR EASY...
01:49:28 Unidentified Speaker YOU HAVE JUST WATCHED A PROGRAM ON CIVILIAN MILITARY RELATIONS. THE EVENT WAS HOSTED BY THE US ARMY...

NOTE: The transcript for this program was compiled from uncorrected Closed Captioning.

RELATED PROGRAMS

PEOPLE GRID LIST

  • Feaver, Peter
  • Herspring, Dale
  • Moten, Matthew
  • Snider, Don
  • Ulrich, Marybeth

PURCHASE