Q & A with Thomas DiLorenzo

Apr 14, 2008

C-SPAN | Q&A

Thomas DiLorenzo spoke about his interests in economics and Abraham Lincoln, and his investigations into the two areas through his books, The Real Lincoln: A New Look at Abraham Lincoln, His Agenda, and an Unnecessary War (Prima Lifestyles, 2002); and Lincoln Unmasked: What You're Not Supposed to Know About Dishonest Abe (Crown .. Read More
Thomas DiLorenzo spoke about his interests in economics and Abraham Lincoln, and his investigations into the two areas through his books, The Real Lincoln: A New Look at Abraham Lincoln, His Agenda, and an Unnecessary War (Prima Lifestyles, 2002); and Lincoln Unmasked: What You're Not Supposed to Know About Dishonest Abe (Crown Forum, 2006). He spoke about his research and methods, as well as many of the results he uncovered during the research. Professor DiLorenzo not only criticizes President Lincoln's handling of the Civil War, he also criticizes current day historians who, he says, belong to the "church of Lincoln." Those include James McPherson, Harold Holzer, Harry Jaffa, Eric Foner, and Doris Kearns Goodwin. Professor DiLorenzo also contends that academic historians critical of Lincoln have difficulties getting university level jobs.

59 minutes | 2,010 Views

SHARE

  • SEND VIDEO
  • POST VIDEO TO FACEBOOK
  • BOOKMARK VIDEO

EMBED THIS VIDEO

Copy the code below and paste it into your website:

MORE OPTIONS

Change Size

TRANSCRIPT

TIME SPEAKER TEXT
00:00:40 Unidentified Speaker THOMAS DILORENZO, WHEN WE FIRST INTERESTED IN ABRAHAM LINCOLN?
00:00:45 Unidentified Speaker I WAS READING ABOUT THE CIVIL WAR, AND I WAS TAKING COURSES AT THE SMITHSONIAN. I AM AN ECONOMIST,...
00:01:17 Unidentified Speaker IN THE LATE 90'S, HOW DID YOU PUSH FOR YOUR FEELING ABOUT THIS?
00:01:25 Unidentified Speaker I WAS IN PENNSYLVANIA, AND I REMEMBER THAT I COULD SING THE BATTLE HYMN OF THE REPUBLIC. I WAS EDUCATED...
00:01:57 Unidentified Speaker HOW WOULD YOU DESCRIBE YOUR FEELINGS ABOUT ABRAHAM LINCOLN?
00:02:03 Unidentified Speaker I TALK ABOUT THE CHURCH OF LINCOLN, I THINK THIS IS VERY UNHEALTHY -- TO DO THIS TO ANY POLITICIAN,...
00:04:29 Unidentified Speaker WHEN DID YOU WRITE YOUR FIRST PIECE ON ABRAHAM LINCOLN?
00:04:34 Unidentified Speaker THIS WAS IN THE INDEPENDENT REVIEW IN 1996. THIS IS AN ACADEMIC JOURNAL. AFTER A COUPLE OF YEARS OF...
00:05:30 Unidentified Speaker HOW WELL DO THESE SELL?
00:05:32 Unidentified Speaker LINCOLN SOLD VERY WELL. THE PERSON WHO WROTE THE FOREWORD TO "THE REAL LINCOLN" IS A PROFESSOR AT...
00:06:17 Unidentified Speaker WHY DO YOU THINK THAT PEOPLE WILL DEIFY HIM?
00:06:24 Unidentified Speaker AFTER THE WAR, AND HIS ASSASSINATION, THE CLERGY BEGAN WITH THE DEIFICATION, THERE WAS AN OLD MAGAZINE...
00:09:07 Unidentified Speaker WHERE DID YOU GET YOUR EDUCATION?
00:09:15 Unidentified Speaker I GOT MADY PH.D. FROM VIRGINIA TECH. THAT IS WHERE I GOT MY PH.D., AND I WAS A STUDENT OF JAMES BUCHANAN...
00:09:48 Unidentified Speaker WHERE DID YOU DO YOUR UNDERGRADUATE WORK?
00:09:52 Unidentified Speaker THIS WAS A SMALL LIBERAL ARTS COLLEGE IN WESTERN PENNSYLVANIA.
00:09:58 Unidentified Speaker AND IN BALTIMORE -- WHAT KIND OF SCHOOL IS THIS?
00:10:02 Unidentified Speaker THIS IS A LIBERAL ARTS COLLEGE, THEY HAVE ABOUT 3500 GRADUATE STUDENTS -- THE EMPHASIS IS ON LIBERAL...
00:10:22 Unidentified Speaker HOW LONG HAVE YOU BEEN THERE?
00:10:25 Unidentified Speaker I HAVE BEEN THERE SINCE 1992.
00:10:30 Unidentified Speaker ONCE YOU BEGAN WRITING THESE BOOKS, HOW DID YOUR LIFE CHANGED?
00:10:37 Unidentified Speaker I HAVE BEEN IN SEVERAL DEBATES, AND -- LAST OCTOBER I WAS IN A DEBATE IN CHICAGO WITH A LOCAL LAWYER...
00:12:08 Unidentified Speaker LET ME FIND OUT SOMETHING ABOUT WHAT YOU WROTE -- THE POLICE ARRESTS AND THE -- PLAYED TOURISTS --...
00:12:31 Unidentified Speaker THE ARE DEVOTED INTO PUTTING OUT THESE PROGRAMS -- THEY ARE DEVOTED IN JUNE PUTTING OUT THESE PROGRAMS....
00:13:38 Unidentified Speaker IF YOU ARE A FARMER -- WHAT DOES THIS MAKE YOU BELIEVE?
00:13:42 Unidentified Speaker YOU BELIEVE THAT PRIVATE PROPERTY IS THE CHIEF FOCUS OF A SOUND ECONOMY AND A FREE SOCIETY, AND THE...
00:14:47 Unidentified Speaker WHAT WOULD ABRAHAM LINCOLN HAVE THOUGHT ABOUT EVERYTHING IF HE HAD BEEN AROUND IN THIS TIME.
00:14:58 Unidentified Speaker I SAY THAT HE IS THE SON OF ALEXANDER HAMILTON. WHEN ALEXANDER HAMILTON WAS THE TREASURY SECRETARY,...
00:18:13 Unidentified Speaker I WANT TO COME BACK TO YOUR RIDING, BUT I HAVE TO ASK YOU, WHY WAS HE A GREAT MAN?
00:18:20 Unidentified Speaker YOU HAVE TO CONSIDER THAT HE HAD LESS THAN ONE YEAR OF FORMAL EDUCATION, AND WAS ONE OF THE GREATEST...
00:20:25 Unidentified Speaker WHY WAS THIS?
00:20:28 Unidentified Speaker I BELIEVE THAT HE HAD THIS IDEA OF UNITY -- HE SPOKE ABOUT THE MEMORY OF UNITY. BUT MOST OF THE AMERICANS...
00:22:11 Unidentified Speaker LET ME READ THE THING THAT YOU WROTE -- WHAT IS BEHIND THIS?
00:22:44 Unidentified Speaker I WENT THROUGH MY ARTICLE, TALKING ABOUT HOW GOODWIN WAS TAKEN OFF OF THE AIR, SHE WAS A NETWORK COMMENTATOR...
00:25:19 Unidentified Speaker YOU ALSO SAY THAT THEY HAVE APPLIED THIS ELSEWHERE?
00:25:23 Unidentified Speaker SHE HAS SPOKEN ABOUT LYNDON JOHNSON, PEOPLE SAY A LOT OF GOOD THINGS ABOUT LYNDON JOHNSON AND HE HAS...
00:26:51 Unidentified Speaker I WANT TO TALK ABOUT THE FIRST SENTENCE, WHAT IS OFA MUSEUM QUALITY SPECIMEN OF A COURT HISTORIAN?...
00:27:03 Unidentified Speaker THIS IS SOMEBODY WHO IS PAID BY THE KING, AND THEY WILL SUPPORT THE INTELLECTUALS -- FOR WHAT THE...
00:27:26 Unidentified Speaker WHO ARE THESE PEOPLE?
00:27:29 Unidentified Speaker WHEN I TALK ABOUT THE CHURCH OF LINCOLN, MUCH OF WHAT WILL MOTIVATE PEOPLE -- THEY WILL TAKE THIS...
00:29:31 Unidentified Speaker ANOTHER COLUMN THAT YOU WROTE -- YOU HAVE ALSO LEARNED THAT THERE IS ONLY ONE GENUINE LINCOLN SCHOLAR,...
00:30:07 Unidentified Speaker THERE IS NOT ENOUGH TIME TO READ EVERYTHING THAT COMES OUT ABOUT LINCOLN. THERE IS A DISTINCT DIFFERENCE...
00:31:28 Unidentified Speaker DEPENDING ON WHATEVER YOU WILL USE, ONE MAN WROTE ABOUT YOU AND THE 14,000 BOOKS WRITTEN ABOUT ABRAHAM...
00:31:45 Unidentified Speaker THERE IS A LARGE GROUP IN THE ACADEMIC WORLD, THEY WRITE THESE AWARDS -- AND IF YOU WANT TO BE A HISTORIAN,...
00:35:14 Unidentified Speaker WERE YOU THE ONLY PERSON WHO WAS AROUND?
00:35:19 Unidentified Speaker I HAVE INTERVIEWED -- THERE WERE MANY BIG CRITICS OF LINCOLN, THEY WOULD FIND ARTICLES IN THE ACADEMIC...
00:37:29 Unidentified Speaker YOU SEE THAT LINCOLN WAS PERSONALLY CORRUPT.
00:37:34 Unidentified Speaker THERE IS A BOOK THAT WAS PUBLISHED IN THE 1920'S, LINCOLN AND THE RAILROAD. HE WAS AN ATTORNEY FOR...
00:40:41 Unidentified Speaker WHAT DO YOU THINK OF THE BICENTENNIAL -- A CELEBRATION OF HIS BIRTH?
00:40:49 Unidentified Speaker THIS IS GOING TO BE A BIG PARTY. ALL THE PEOPLE ON THIS COMMISSION -- THEY ARE PUTTING ON THE TELEVISION...
00:41:55 Unidentified Speaker IF THEY WOULD INVITE YOU TO BE ON THE COMMISSION, WHAT WOULD YOU SAY?
00:42:01 Unidentified Speaker I DID NOT KNOW IF THEY WOULD LISTEN, BUT I WOULD TELL THEM -- THERE ARE TWO SIDES TO EVERY POLITICAL...
00:42:21 Unidentified Speaker YOU HAVE GONE TO MOST OF THE PLACES ACROSS THE COUNTRY? YOU HAVE GONE TO FORD'S THEATRE?
00:42:32 Unidentified Speaker LINCOLN MEMORIAL, I HAVE BEEN THERE SEVERAL TIMES.
00:42:36 Unidentified Speaker SHOULD THERE BE A LINCOLN MEMORIAL?
00:42:39 Unidentified Speaker THERE NEEDS TO BE A LINCOLN MEMORIAL, AND IF PEOPLE WANT TO HAVE A MEMORY OF THE PRESIDENT -- THE...
00:43:43 Unidentified Speaker HAVE THEY EVER ASK YOU TO SPEAK IN THE LINCOLN FORUM?
00:43:50 Unidentified Speaker I HAVE NEVER INVITED ME TO SPEAK HERE. IT DEPENDS ON THE GROUND RULES. I HAVE BEEN AROUND THEM BEFORE,...
00:44:31 Unidentified Speaker WHAT WAS THE FOCUS? WHAT DID THEY WANT TO DO? WHAT WAS THIS DOCUMENTARY ABOUT?
00:44:40 Unidentified Speaker THE DOCUMENTARY WAS TALKING ABOUT A SERIES ON AMERICAN PRESIDENTS. THEY WERE SPEAKING ABOUT MOST OF...
00:45:55 Unidentified Speaker AFTER THE BOOK CAME OUT, THERE WAS A LOT OF FAN MAIL, THOUSANDS OF BITS OF THE MAIL FROM AROUND THE...
00:47:19 Unidentified Speaker DID YOU DO THE OTHER THING OR DID YOU BALANCE THIS?
00:47:23 Unidentified Speaker THE CONFERENCE IS THE BALANCE. THERE WAS -- THERE WAS A QUESTION AND ANSWER SESSION AFTER EACH PRESENTATION....
00:48:36 Unidentified Speaker THIS IS THE MAN AT GETTYSBURG COLLEGE?
00:48:39 Unidentified Speaker THIS WAS NOT THE MAN. DURING THE DISCUSSION, HE WAS CALLING TO SAY THINGS LIKE NO PRIVATE PROPERTY...
00:50:30 Unidentified Speaker THE 13TH AMENDMENT FREED THE SLAVES, LINCOLN -- HE WAS SUPPORTING THE AMENDMENT. SOME OF THESE STATES...
00:52:35 Unidentified Speaker IF YOU SPEAK ABOUT THESE CULTISTS, THE MEMBERS OF THE CHURCH OF LINCOLN -- IF YOU WERE GOING TO TELL...
00:52:55 Unidentified Speaker I HAVE TO COME BACK TO THE TRUTH OF HISTORY -- THERE WAS ONE DEBATE THAT I WAS IN, THIS WAS PUBLISHED...
00:53:43 Unidentified Speaker HOW WOULD YOU EMBARRASS THEM?
00:53:46 Unidentified Speaker I THINK THAT SOME OF THESE PEOPLE ARE MORE THOUGHTFUL, THEY MAY LOOK AT WHAT THEY HAVE BEEN DOING...
00:54:30 Unidentified Speaker IS THERE A LEADER?
00:54:35 Unidentified Speaker THERE ARE MANY PEOPLE WHO THINK ABOUT THEMSELVES AS LEADERS. THERE IS A MAN WITH A NUMBER OF ARGUMENTS...
00:55:30 Unidentified Speaker WHO ELSE IS ON THE LIST?
00:55:36 Unidentified Speaker JAMES MCPHERSON OF PRINCETON -- THERE WAS THE DEBATE WITH ANOTHER HISTORIAN, IN NORTH AND SOUTH MAGAZINE....
00:57:20 Unidentified Speaker WHO HAVE THE GREATEST IMPACT ON YOU, BESIDES THE PEOPLE WHO YOU HAVE SPOKEN ABOUT, THAT MAY HAVE PUT...
00:57:31 Unidentified Speaker THIS IS PROBABLY JUST THE EDUCATION. I WAS READING WILLIAM FRIEDMAN, THERE WAS A MAGAZINE MADE FROM...
00:58:16 Unidentified Speaker AND YOU HAVE ANOTHER BOOK THAT IS COMING OUT?
00:58:23 Unidentified Speaker THIS IS OCTOBER 2008, HOW THE ARCHENEMY THE TRADE THE AMERICAN REVOLUTION. -- THE TRADE -- BUT TRADE...
00:58:49 Unidentified Speaker THANK YOU VERY MUCH, THOMAS DILORENZO, THE AUTHOR OF "LINCOLN UNMASKED: WHAT YOU'RE NOT SUPPOSED TO...
00:59:03 Unidentified Speaker THANK YOU.
00:59:08 Unidentified Speaker FOR A COPY ON VHS TAPE OR DVD, PLEASE CALL THE NUMBER ON THE SCREEN. FOR A TRANSCRIPT OR TO GIVE US...

NOTE: The transcript for this program was compiled from uncorrected Closed Captioning.

RELATED PROGRAMS

PEOPLE GRID LIST

  • DiLorenzo, Thomas J.
  • Lamb, Brian

PURCHASE